Cat Sitting in Middle Island

Book a cat sitter to stop by your home to feed and play with your cat.

End
Search

Every sitter passes an enhanced background check. Learn about RoverProtect

Top rated Middle Island cat sitters

Prices are estimates per visit. Pricing may vary based on your search. A booking fee of 11% and taxes will apply.

1 / 1
Sitter Profile Image: Allison M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Allison M.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
12 reviews
4 repeat clients
10 years of experience
Miller Place, NY, 11764

Allison did a great job with our kitten Jon Snow! She left numerous feedback and pictures and they seemed to be having a real good time. I highly recommend Allison!

Profile image
Kenneth J.
Sitter Profile Image: Amanda M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amanda M.
Star Sitter
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
21 reviews
5 repeat clients
15 years of experience
Farmingville, NY, 11738

Fantastic care for unusual animals. Amanda was so diligent with the feeding needs of my turtle. She even volunteered a lettuce leaf as a snack. She took great care of the fish without overfeeding and provided medical care for one of them. Then she very kindly agreed to water my plants. Pictures and videos everyday. Lots of communication. I will absolutely use her again and you should too. If she does this well with a turtle, imagine how great you'll be with your cats and dogs.

Profile image
Veronica G.
Sitter Profile Image: Emma B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Emma B.
from
$20
per visit
5 years of experience
Ridge, NY, 11961

About: I've been taking care of family, friends, and neighbors animals since I was little. I've been working and volunteering at a local animal rescue for almost two years, and am comfortable and familiar with dogs of any kind, age, temperament, and more! I'm not afraid to clean up or play with a dog with energy, I've seen it all and have experience with hundreds of dogs! I am student at Virginia Tech, so coming home over the summer leaves me totally free! I'm eager to have something to fill my time, especially if it's checking in on a puppy every few hours, or getting me active while I'm on break. I have so much experience with maintaining a dogs environment and health, and can predict dogs needs based on behavior from my time working with them! I have worked with service dogs, special needs dogs, elderly dogs, almost newborn puppies, and more. Each dog is different and I love learning their needs and patterns over time.

Sitter Profile Image: stephanie s.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
stephanie s.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
30 reviews
7 repeat clients
5 years of experience
manorville, NY, 11949

Stephanie is amazing! She is very reliable and always comes in with a great attitude. I would trust her with all my pets and she really helped us out when work schedules are crazy and I work late at night.

Profile image
Marissa S.
Sitter Profile Image: jacy p.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
jacy p.
from
$15
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
73 reviews
22 repeat clients
45 years of experience
Yaphank, NY, 11980

Jacy took great care of our two boys. She was always on time and kept us well informed. Jacy gave us peace of mind knowing our furry boys were in good hands.

Profile image
Jaime P.
Sitter Profile Image: Gerri G.
Verified Background Check
Gerri G.
Star Sitter
from
$30
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
132 reviews
41 repeat clients
20 years of experience
Coram, NY, 11727

Gerri is just fantastic! She is great with the dogs and is very easy to communicate with. It gives me peace of mind to know that she is able to take care of our dogs while we are not there.

Profile image
Kalle M.
Sitter Profile Image: antonia m.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
antonia m.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 reviews
50 years of experience
Ridge, NY, 11961

About: Animals have been a part of my life since childhood, and I'm surrounded by them every day. I have experience caring for dogs, cats, horses, goats, rats and more. Every dog I've owned has been personally trained by me, giving me hands-on experience with behavior, structure, and individualized care. I live on a small farm and work from home, so I'm available throughout the day for animal's needs. Caring for horses, dogs, and cats is already a part of my daily routine, making pet care a natural part of my lifestyle. I have a fully fenced yard and two friendly dogs that can provide companionship for social dogs. I'm experienced in safely managing separate spaces if a dog prefers to be alone of is not dog-friendly, ensuring every pet gets plenty of personalized care, attention, and outdoor time.

Sitter Profile Image: Emma & Trent A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Emma & Trent A.
Star Sitter
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
36 reviews
13 repeat clients
6 years of experience
Centereach, NY, 11720

Thank you so much for taking such good care of our girls. They are so excited to see you each time you visit. Reagan shows off with her happy dance and Peaches does the same with her big tail wag. We can’t say enough about your professionalism and how well you care for our girls. They definitely love your company! Thanks again - especially with such short notice. We truly appreciate you!! ☺️☺️

Profile image
Laura
Sitter Profile Image: Lauren F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Lauren F.
from
$15
per visit
4.8 out of 5 stars
4 reviews
2 repeat clients
12 years of experience
Coram, NY, 11727

About: I have been taking care animals since I was 15. I have been a licensed tech for two years. I can administer oral meds, insulin and sq fluids if necessary. I know how to love and care for your pet properly. Wether is be shorter walks because it is too hot outside or making sure your pet has proper playtime and enough mental stimulation. Your pet is in safe hands with me and I can’t wait to take care of them ☺️. I am currently unemployed so I have been dog walking and sitting full time, this way I can devote all my attention to caring for your pet. I will be able to come over for drop in visits, walks and dog sit short term and long term at your house for extended periods of time while you are away. My top priority is to make sure your pet is stress free so anything more I can do, please let know! I will take care of your dog like she is my own. I have a fenced in yard and a pup at my home for them to play with. When your dog is on walks, they will be fully supervised. They will get all my attention, lots of pets and of course playtime when I come over for drop ins. I can even offer hikes to pet parents that can’t get their dogs outside while they are at work or out.

Sitter Profile Image: Kim M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kim M.
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
1 review
3 repeat clients
10 years of experience
Ridge, NY, 11961

About: I've always been such a huge animal lover and always took care of my own cats, dogs, guinea pigs and birds. I used to watch my family members pets when they would go away and feed them per special instructions and stayed with them as long as I could so they were never lonely. I work full time now but I make my own schedule! I'll be able to be reliable and work around the needs of anyone's babies! In my clients home I always have respect and take care of not only the pets but the home and property when I'm there always.

Sitter Profile Image: Madison R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Madison R.
Star Sitter
from
$24
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
39 reviews
12 repeat clients
14 years of experience
Holtsville, NY, 11742

I had never had a Pet Sitter before and I picked Madison to be the first one and I never could’ve chosen a better Pet Sitter! She took wonderful care of my cat family and they are my family. They’re my kids. I have four of them she showed up every day that I asked her too. She took care of the kids so wonderfully. I can’t even begin to tell you it was awesome! I would recommend Madison as a pet sitter to anybody and I can’t wait till my next trip because I will be requesting if she is free for her to watch my kittens again! She took wonderful care of them. She bought in a box for me that was delivered. I didn’t even know it was going to come and she had no problem with that she showed up on time stayed as long as she was supposed to played with the cat. Send me pictures of playing with the cats and cats are your family. That’s really really important! I have no children. They are my children and she watched my children perfectly thank you Madison!

Profile image
Donna C.
Sitter Profile Image: Jamey O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Jamey O.
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 reviews
1 repeat client
15 years of experience
Oakdale, NY, 11769

Jamey visited my newly adopted senior cat three times a day for three days. She fed her, gave her medications, cleaned her litter box and kept her company. It’s so comforting to know that I can enjoy my little vacations while my cat is well cared for back at home.

Profile image
Toni C.
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa & Michael W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Lisa & Michael W.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
285 reviews
118 repeat clients
40 years of experience
East patchogue, NY, 11772

Lisa and Michael dropped in to feed and let my dogs out. They did such a wonderful job and my pups love them! My small dog is a flight risk. L&M took so many precautions to ensure she didn’t run out. The first thing they did was make sure the gate and fence line was secure before letting my dogs out. It’s that level of experience and care that set these two wonderful people apart. My older dog had an accident and they cleaned everything up so well. It was such a relief to not have to worry about a mess when I arrived home later that night.

Profile image
Carly P.
Sitter Profile Image: Ioanna F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Ioanna F.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
37 reviews
10 repeat clients
4 years of experience
rocky point, NY, 11778

I cannot express how grateful and delighted I am to have found Ioanna as my dog walker! From day one, she has gone above and beyond in taking care of my beloved fur baby. And a quiet recently added fur baby. Every time Waffles and Rain goes out with Ioanna, they come back happy and content, clearly having had a wonderful time on their adventures. What truly sets her apart is the genuine love and affection displayed towards my pups and the attention to detail in her service. During days of care, Ioanna ensured that Waffles and Rain always had plenty of water and a comfortable, place to rest. On rainy days, we could always count on high spirits and excellent care, never once cancelling due to weather. Moreover, her flexibility and reliability are commendable, accommodating any last-minute schedule changes with a smile. In addition to providing outstanding walks, Ioanna goes the extra mile, sending updates and adorable pictures from the walk and fun times during visits, which always brighten my day. It's comforting to know my pups are in such capable and caring hands. I wholeheartedly recommend Ioanna to anyone in need of a trustworthy and exceptional dog walker. Thanks to her, not only are Waffles and Rain healthier and happier, but we have found peace of mind knowing they’re in such wonderful care. Thank you, Ioanna, for being such a fantastic and compassionate friend to my beloved pups. I’m so lucky to have you!

Profile image
Geovany Y. M.
Sitter Profile Image: Kellie E.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kellie E.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
2 reviews
1 repeat client
10 years of experience
Ridge, NY, 11961

About: I have grown up with 4 dogs maximum in my house. I am super comfortable around any dog. Sweet, kind, aggressive, scared, anxious and whatever else you have to throw at me! I love dogs of all age! Puppies and old fur babies will be loved the same! Let’s connect! I am fairly open and will constantly communicate. I work at a dentist office and I clean pools in the summer! I’m also doing my masters online. I keep the house in the condition it was left to me, I’m able to take out the trash, water flowers and bring in mail. I will fully be in communication with the owners. The animals will always have their breakfast, dinner and treats! If medicine is needed, I will try my best to give that to them. Walks and playing in the backyard is a must! I am more than happy to share the bed with them as well. The most important factor is the endless cuddles!

Sitter Profile Image: Brooke J.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Brooke J.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
6 reviews
1 repeat client
38 years of experience
Rocky Point, NY, 11778

About: I bring years of hands-on experience caring for both dogs and cats of all ages, breeds, and temperaments—including puppies, high-energy dogs, senior pets, and shy or special-needs cats. I’m comfortable with administering medications (oral, topical, and injections), caring for pets with anxiety, and supporting senior animals with mobility issues or extra comfort needs. What sets me apart is my calm, attentive nature and my ability to quickly bond with animals. I tailor each visit to fit your pet’s unique personality—whether that means structured play and training for a puppy, slow walks and joint care for a senior dog, or quiet companionship for a sensitive cat. I’m also a bit of a neat freak, so I make sure litter boxes, food bowls, and pet spaces stay fresh and clean. I care for your pets like they’re family—because that’s exactly how they deserve to be treated. Pet care is a natural part of my daily routine—I build my schedule around the needs of the fur babies I care for. Whether it’s morning feedings, midday playtime, or evening check-ins, I’m flexible and dependable. I prioritize consistency and create a calm, familiar environment for each pet, making sure they feel secure even when their humans are away. Whether it’s a short visit or an extended stay, I’m fully present and committed to giving your pets the care and attention they deserve every single day. When caring for pets in a client’s home, safety, trust, and respect are my top priorities. I follow all care instructions to the letter, from feeding schedules and medication needs to favorite toys and hiding spots. I make sure doors, windows, and food storage are secure, and I’m mindful of any hazards specific to your home or your pets behavior. I treat your space with the same respect I’d want for my own—clean, tidy, and exactly as you left it. I also provide regular updates with photos or messages, so you can have peace of mind knowing your pets are safe, happy, and in loving hands.

Sitter Profile Image: Isabella A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Isabella A.
from
$35
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
4 reviews
1 repeat client
7 years of experience
Medford, NY, 11763

Bella was a pleasure to work with. She stays in touch leading up to the visit and afterward. She also did a great job of calming one of our more skittish kitties during our interview. We love the picture updates from the visit - thank you for those. Will definitely book again!

Profile image
Kris and Shannon D.
Sitter Profile Image: Kelly C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kelly C.
Star Sitter
from
$28
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
22 reviews
12 repeat clients
16 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

Kelly is amazing! She was very quick to respond and was able to help us out when our usual sitter cancelled last minute. She took great care of our puppy and provided lots of updates!

Profile image
Kuldeep M.
Sitter Profile Image: Christine M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Christine M.
from
$30
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
27 reviews
6 repeat clients
12 years of experience
Port Jefferson Station, NY, 11776

Christine was fabulous. She was conscientious and took great care of our cat. She is the first cat sitter we’ve booked (of 2-3 Rover sitters) who has actually come at exactly the time we asked her, consistently. Beyond that, when our travel plans had to change because of airline problems, Christine kindly agreed to extend the booking - even though it was the holidays and I’m sure she had other obligations.

Profile image
Lori K.
Sitter Profile Image: Chris D.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Chris D.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
42 reviews
14 repeat clients
6 years of experience
Rocky Point, NY, 11778

About: I have my own home with a fenced in backyard, I love hiking and running the trails. I have 5 fur-nephews and nieces and haven’t met a dog that I haven’t befriended. I work a steady full time job at a bakery in the Holbrook costco so I am always home before dinner and I always smell delicious. I have a fully fenced in backyard with a back door access, I have also had my friends and family dogs in my household for extended periods with great success.

1 / 1
View more sitters

Over 19
pet parents in Middle Island have booked cat sitting

How Rover works

  1. 1. Search

    Read verified reviews by cat parents like you and choose a sitter who’s a great match for you and your cat
  2. 2. Meet & Greet

    Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your cat while you’re away
  3. 3. Book & Pay

    All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!

The median cost per night for cat sitting in Middle Island is $25

Why Choose Rover?

  • Cashless payments

    Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.

  • Reservation protection

    It doesn’t happen often, but if your cat sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.

  • World-class support

    We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total cat fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.

Sitters in Middle Island average 3
repeat cat sitting clients

Cat Sitting FAQs

Frequently asked questions about Rover

Cat sitters on Rover are free to set their rates. The median cost to hire a cat sitter in Middle Island on Rover as of Jun 2026 was about $25 per night, after factoring in Rover’s service fees. A cat sitter’s rate may also change as you customize your booking to fit your and your cat’s needs.

If you’re searching for a Middle Island cat sitter for the first time, visit the cat sitter’s profile and select the Contact button.

If you have an active request or have booked a service with a cat sitter before, learn more about how to do this in the Rover app or on your computer.

As of Jun 2026, there are 41 cat sitters in Middle Island. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.

Rover makes it easy to reach out to multiple cat sitters about your booking. Typically, 93% of Middle Island cat sitters respond in under an hour.

Cat sitters with repeat customers have an average of 3 repeat clients. Experience can vary from cat sitter to cat sitter, but you can view reviews, years of experience, and number of repeat clients when you compare cat sitters in Middle Island.

Do you simply need someone to stop by and play, feed, and scoop? Middle Island cat sitters are happy to take care of your cat while you’re at work, on vacation, or unavailable for the day, even if all you need is a quick drop-in! Your cat sitter will stop by to feed, play with, and snuggle your cat as many times a day as you like. And the best part? Your cat gets to stay on their home turf.

There are 41 cat sitters in Middle Island on Rover, so you’re sure to find the perfect match for your cat! We understand that each cat is unique and may require specific instructions. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.

Yes! Cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check before offering their services. You can also easily keep in touch with your cat sitter through messages on Rover for delightful photo updates. The Rover team is available 24/7, and your cat sitter has access to advice from qualified veterinary professionals. In the rare event of any issues during a booking, rest easy knowing your cat is covered by the Rover Guarantee reimbursement program for eligible veterinary care.

Note: If your cat sitter requested to cancel this booking, then they need to cancel from their account. Please contact them via Rover Messages.

We get it—sometimes plans change and you may need to cancel your cat sitting service. You can cancel an upcoming booking directly from the Rover app or your computer, in accordance with your cat sitter’s cancellation policy.