Cat Sitting in Bay Shore

Book a cat sitter to stop by your home to feed and play with your cat.

End
Search

Every sitter passes an enhanced background check. Learn about RoverProtect

Top rated Bay Shore cat sitters

Prices are estimates per visit. Pricing may vary based on your search. A booking fee of 11% and taxes will apply.

1 / 1
Sitter Profile Image: Ericka R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Ericka R.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
44 reviews
23 repeat clients
35 years of experience
Brightwaters, NY, 11718

She is great!!! We are very happy we had Ericka’s help. She was very sweet with our Harper. Definitely we will call her again in the future.

Profile image
Cristina T.
Sitter Profile Image: Gerald C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Gerald C.
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
8 reviews
1 repeat client
40 years of experience
Islip, NY, 11751

About: I’m a retired professional with a calm, patient nature and a genuine love for animals. My sister has two dogs, one of whom is a super senior with special needs, so I’m very comfortable providing extra attention, patience, and thoughtful care. With a flexible schedule and plenty of time to devote to one-on-one care, I enjoy creating a safe, comfortable, and loving environment for dogs and cats. Whether it’s daily walks, playtime, medication routines, or quiet companionship, I treat every pet as if they were my own—offering reliable care and true peace of mind to pet parents. Pet care fits very naturally into my daily and weekly routine. As a retired professional, I have a flexible schedule that allows me to plan my day around a pet’s needs rather than the other way around. I’m home for most of the day, which means plenty of time for walks, play, feeding, medication schedules, and quiet companionship. I enjoy building consistent routines that help pets feel secure and comfortable, and I’m able to give them my full attention without feeling rushed. This flexibility also allows me to adapt easily to senior pets or those with special needs who may require extra time, patience, or monitoring. I tailor my care to each pet’s individual routine, personality, and needs—whether in my home or in a client’s home. I follow all feeding schedules carefully, provide fresh water, regular walks or playtime, and plenty of attention and companionship. I’m especially attentive to senior and special-needs pets, including administering medications as directed and keeping a calm, consistent environment. In a client’s home, I respect their routines and space, making sure pets feel secure and comfortable in their familiar surroundings. I also keep pet parents updated with check-ins and notes so they can feel confident their pets are happy, safe, and well cared for while they’re away.

Sitter Profile Image: Joanne B.
Verified Background Check
Joanne B.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
174 reviews
72 repeat clients
20 years of experience
Islip, NY, 11751

Joanne took care of our 3 pets during drop-in visits over a 3-day period. Joanne showed great care while feeding and interacting with Fiona (our 10 year old pit bull), Davlin (our 17 year old frail cat), as well as Moshie (our shy 13 year old cat). Joanne provided detailed information regarding her care for the individual needs of each of our pets during each visit. She also provided numerous photos of each animal while visiting. Prior to her drop-ins, Joanne came over for a Meet and Greet in order to go over details while visiting, as well as getting to meet our pets. In addition, Joanne kept us up to date with each interaction while visiting and any questions or concerns that she or we may have had during the visits. Without a doubt Joanne demonstrates a tremendous amount of care and professionalism in every aspect while working with us and caring for Fiona, Davlin and Moshie. I look forward to having Joanne care for our pets in the future, as well as highly recommend anyone who has a need for someone to care for their pets.

Profile image
Michael And Mary F.
Sitter Profile Image: Steff S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Steff S.
from
$19
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
52 reviews
15 repeat clients
20 years of experience
East Islip, NY, 11730

This was our second time with Steff caring for our two (very needy) sphynx cats and, once again, she was very attentive and professional. As other reviews have noted, Steff loves animals and she provided great care while maintaining frequent communication while we were on vacation. Steff sent lots of photos of the cats at play, which is always reassuring when you are thousands of miles away, and they clearly enjoy her company. We highly recommend Steff to take care of your pet or pets and we hope to use her next time we are away.

Profile image
LAURENCE S.
Sitter Profile Image: Abby R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Abby R.
Star Sitter
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
22 reviews
7 repeat clients
2 years of experience
Islip, NY, 11751

About: I have taken care of pets since I was 5 years old. That includes dogs, cats, lizards, snakes. I love them all. They love me. unfortunately, my apartment complex does not allow Pitbulls sorry I can cover most days and evening needs. I have the needed transportation to meet your needs. I am ready to help you any way I can. I can care for your pets needs in your home or my apartment. I am flexible in doing whatever is required to meet your needs

Sitter Profile Image: Shelby S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Shelby S.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
22 reviews
9 repeat clients
5 years of experience
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Shelby was absolutely wonderful with our cats Peanut & Simba. She was communicative and sent us pictures regularly during her visits. We will definitely be using her services again in the future!!

Profile image
Ashley L.
Sitter Profile Image: Kristina B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kristina B.
Star Sitter
from
$30
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
45 reviews
14 repeat clients
35 years of experience
Deer Park, NY, 11729

Kristina did me a huge favor and took my cat to the vet last min when I couldn’t. She was nice and sweet with the my car would use her again.

Profile image
Kristina S.
Sitter Profile Image: Nadine B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Nadine B.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
35 reviews
11 repeat clients
7 years of experience
West Islip, NY, 11795

Nadine is absolutely wonderful with my two senior dachshunds and the senior conure. Before we went away for a few days, Nadine came to the house four times to get to know the dogs and the conure and to spend time with them. The “kids” love her and respond to Nadine as if she were an old friend. Our oldest doxie is a 30 lb standard who no longer does stairs, so he needs to be lifted up and down from the back stoop every time he goes out. The catch is that although the old boy won’t climb stairs, he suddenly thinks he’s Superman and can jump! Nadine quickly mastered the correct lift and block to get him up and down safely. Nadine kept in touch and checked in and out and sent extra pictures each of the three times she visited each day which was very reassuring. I know the dogs were in great hands, and so do they; and I know that because When I got home, they did not rush to see me to complain. They were welcoming and happy and totally at ease. We will absolutely use Nadine the next time we have to leave the dogs(and the bird).

Profile image
MK B.
Sitter Profile Image: Jenn B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Jenn B.
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
2 reviews
6 years of experience
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

About: Hi, I’m Jenn! I have been a dog walker and pet sitter since 2017 and have over 750 5 star reviews on Wag! I am excited to expand my services to Rover! I have experience with puppies through 16 year old pups. I also have experience caring for cats. I am trained in Pet CPR and First Aid. I am comfortable giving oral medications. I love making sure your furry friends have the most fun and stay safe. I can’t wait to meet your pets! I am a teacher and work on a teacher’s schedule. Therefore, I am available for services in the evenings, on weekends, and school vacations. Feel free to reach out if you have a question about a particular date. I always make sure to follow client’s instructions for walking, feeding, and medications. Safety is always my number one priority. I am only able to care for pets in your home because I cannot have animals in my apartment.

Sitter Profile Image: Sandy K.
Verified Background Check
Sandy K.
Star Sitter
from
$27
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
198 reviews
81 repeat clients
20 years of experience
East Islip, NY, 11730

Sandy was amazing with Chansey!! So grateful to have found her on this app. And I look forward to Sandy caring for her again in the future. Thanks Sandy, for loving on my little Chansey girl xoxo

Profile image
Jenny C.
Sitter Profile Image: Donna C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Donna C.
from
$15
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
4 reviews
20 years of experience
West Islip, NY, 11795

About: Being around animals brings me joy and I want them to feel at ease because I know they are missing their pet parents. My calm, patient and kind personality will be comforting to your pet. I’ve given medications and have cared for many types of dogs and cats as well as chickens, birds and a duck! I am also very conscientious about safety, being on time and keeping your home tidy. When you return home it will be as you left it and to happy pets! I am recently retired, therefore my schedule is flexible daily, including weekends and overnights. Let me know what your needs are and I will do my best to accommodate. I can pet sit in your home. I do not have my own pets but family members I live with have 2 cats that I often help care for. Safety and caring for your home and pets are important to me. You will return to a tidy home. I am happy to discuss how to accommodate your needs.

Sitter Profile Image: Hannah S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Hannah S.
from
$40
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
18 reviews
8 repeat clients
5 years of experience
islip, NY, 11751

"Absolutely incredible experience! Hannah was everything we could have hoped for and more. Our 100-pound Newfoundland, Arto, absolutely adored them. They were reliable, professional, and managed Arto’s size and energy with ease. It’s not always easy to find someone who can handle such a large dog, but Hannah made it look effortless. They kept us updated with pictures and notes, and we could tell Arto was happy, well cared for, and having a great time. We wouldn’t hesitate to book Hannah again—highly recommend!"

Profile image
Shannon S.
Sitter Profile Image: Alex B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Alex B.
from
$30
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
72 reviews
23 repeat clients
10 years of experience
Babylon, NY, 11702

Alex did such a wonderful job taking care of my cat!! He went above and beyond with pictures, checking in with me, and following all the directions. I can tell he truly cares for animals and is incredibly responsible. Would recommend to anyone.

Profile image
Helen G.
Sitter Profile Image: Tamekia S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Tamekia S.
from
$18
per visit
3 years of experience
Deer Park, NY, 11729

About: I enjoy cats and dogs as I have had my own, currently pet sit for my roommates cats while she’s on vacation. Cuddle puddles are my favorite pastime Evenings and weekends are preferred, can be flexible. I can do drop ins anytime past 6pm on the weekdays and anytime on the weekends. Emergency calls can also be arranged. I care for pets by slowly introducing myself, first by smell then when comfortable, by touch. I give treats when warranted, but ensure no over feeding/snacking. Lastly I cuddle with pets who are most comfortable.

Sitter Profile Image: Amber O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amber O.
Star Sitter
from
$25
per visit
5.0 out of 5 stars
84 reviews
25 repeat clients
15 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

She has been doing an excellent job keeping me informed every day and sending me pictures I highly recommend amber and will be using her in the future

Profile image
Tara D.
Sitter Profile Image: Jess P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Jess P.
from
$30
per visit
4.9 out of 5 stars
44 reviews
15 repeat clients
10 years of experience
Central Islip, NY, 11787

Jess took care of my pup Leia while I was away for the day at a baseball game and sent me update photos each visit and some comments on how the visit went. Leia had a lot of fun. Will definitely use Jess again!

Profile image
James M.
Sitter Profile Image: Darlene A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Darlene A.
from
$25
per visit
20 years of experience
Islip, NY, 11751

About: I’ve had and taken care of cats and dogs of all sizes. I love all animals and take pride and joy in helping care for people’s pets I am currently a stay at home mom to a two year old boy and i have open availability most days of the week including weekends. I am very responsible and will be sure to close any gates and keep the dogs on leash I am able to administer medication if needed.

Sitter Profile Image: Jennifer G.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Jennifer G.
from
$25
per visit
4.8 out of 5 stars
26 reviews
8 repeat clients
30 years of experience
Babylon, NY, 11702

Jennifer was great! She was very attentive and caring towards our cat, Luci, during the five days we were out of town. Luci did not get herself into trouble during that time, and I am very grateful Jennifer was there to check up on her. I would definitely recommend Jennifer’s pet services!

Profile image
Senia L.
Sitter Profile Image: Junianna B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Junianna B.
from
$17
per visit
5 years of experience
North Babylon, NY, 11703

About: Dog walking is something I love to do. I take my dog (a boisterous standard schnauzer with quite the mind of his own!) on a walk everyday and love to help others out by giving their pup some exercise! I know that all dogs are unique, so I will take great care to make sure that I follow any instructions given and make this a great experience for the dog. I am good at reading a dog’s body language and know techniques to help calm a dog down if it gets overstimulated and will take necessary steps to ensure the dog’s comfort. I also know my way around the neighborhood, and can take the pup to new and exciting places (within the owners comfort level of course!) so they have a great time! As a recent college graduate, I have a very flexible schedule with ample time to dedicate to taking care of pets. I usually do morning and evening walks (as to avoid too high temperatures) and throughout the day can provide general pet care. I have a large, fenced in yard that pups can run freely in with my own dog. There is also a pool that they can use (under strict supervision of course!) and they have free access to all areas inside the house. We are also conscientious about making sure there are no dangerous things lying around (eg. socks, small items) that the dog can get to.

Sitter Profile Image: Brooke H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Brooke H.
from
$25
per visit
10 years of experience
East Islip, NY, 11730

About: I have had dogs in my family since the day I was born. I am 24 years old, and I am currently raising a two-year-old and a three-year-old black lab. I have a love for animals like no other, and in the last two years, my family has had two puppies, along with our nine-year-old black lab. I am a licensed real estate agent and therefore have a flexible schedule in order to care for your pets during the week and possible weekends. I have a fenced and gated yard at my house. Along with that, I have collars and leashes that can be used for a walk or exercise in general. We also have a two-story house which gives lots of room for exploring and comfort.

1 / 1
View more sitters

Over 27
pet parents in Bay Shore have booked cat sitting

Bay Shore cat parents share their Rover experiences

1 / 1
5.0 out of 5 stars

From the initial meet and greet it was very clear that Ericka would genuinely look after my babies. She was sure to be prompt with her drop-ins and provide the necessary care for my two cats, and update me daily on their wellbeing. I was so far away but I felt very assured that they were being well taken care of. If you are looking for peace of mind, look no further. Thank you so much Ericka!

Profile image
Hossain U.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5 stars

Cleo was well taken care of and I was updated every step of the way. I felt at ease knowing that Shelby was being so attentive and caring for my girl. I'll definitely be rebooking next time I need a sitter.

Profile image
Paige R.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5 stars

Absolutely amazing as always! She is the sweetest! I can go on vacation knowing my babies are being well taken care of!

Profile image
Ashley S.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5 stars

Billie was very responsible, always checked in on time, and followed the schedule well. She took great care of Cosmo’s needs and was very loving with him. I felt reassured knowing he was in good hands.

Profile image
Varsha S.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5 stars

Thank you so much, Gabriella, for taking care of our family. It means a great deal to have peace of mind when you take a vacation knowing your pets are cared for!

Profile image
Keri L.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5 stars

Joanne took care of our 3 pets during drop-in visits over a 3-day period. Joanne showed great care while feeding and interacting with Fiona (our 10 year old pit bull), Davlin (our 17 year old frail cat), as well as Moshie (our shy 13 year old cat). Joanne provided detailed information regarding her care for the individual needs of each of our pets during each visit. She also provided numerous photos of each animal while visiting. Prior to her drop-ins, Joanne came over for a Meet and Greet in order to go over details while visiting, as well as getting to meet our pets. In addition, Joanne kept us up to date with each interaction while visiting and any questions or concerns that she or we may have had during the visits. Without a doubt Joanne demonstrates a tremendous amount of care and professionalism in every aspect while working with us and caring for Fiona, Davlin and Moshie. I look forward to having Joanne care for our pets in the future, as well as highly recommend anyone who has a need for someone to care for their pets.

Profile image
Michael And Mary F.
Drop-In Visits
1 / 1
Find pet care near you

How Rover works

  1. 1. Search

    Read verified reviews by cat parents like you and choose a sitter who’s a great match for you and your cat
  2. 2. Meet & Greet

    Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your cat while you’re away
  3. 3. Book & Pay

    All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!

The median cost per night for cat sitting in Bay Shore is $25

Why Choose Rover?

  • Cashless payments

    Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.

  • Reservation protection

    It doesn’t happen often, but if your cat sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.

  • World-class support

    We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total cat fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.

Sitters in Bay Shore average 5
repeat cat sitting clients

Cat Sitting FAQs

Frequently asked questions about Rover

Cat sitters on Rover are free to set their rates. The median cost to hire a cat sitter in Bay Shore on Rover as of Jun 2026 was about $25 per night, after factoring in Rover’s service fees. A cat sitter’s rate may also change as you customize your booking to fit your and your cat’s needs.

If you’re searching for a Bay Shore cat sitter for the first time, visit the cat sitter’s profile and select the Contact button.

If you have an active request or have booked a service with a cat sitter before, learn more about how to do this in the Rover app or on your computer.

As of Jun 2026, there are 548 cat sitters in Bay Shore. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.

Rover makes it easy to reach out to multiple cat sitters about your booking. Typically, 80% of Bay Shore cat sitters respond in under an hour.

Cat sitters in Bay Shore have an average of 16 years of experience. Cat sitters with repeat customers have an average of 5 repeat clients. Experience can vary from cat sitter to cat sitter, but you can view reviews, years of experience, and number of repeat clients when you compare cat sitters in Bay Shore.

Do you simply need someone to stop by and play, feed, and scoop? Bay Shore cat sitters are happy to take care of your cat while you’re at work, on vacation, or unavailable for the day, even if all you need is a quick drop-in! Your cat sitter will stop by to feed, play with, and snuggle your cat as many times a day as you like. And the best part? Your cat gets to stay on their home turf.

There are 548 cat sitters in Bay Shore on Rover, so you’re sure to find the perfect match for your cat! In Bay Shore, 94% of cat sitters offer daily exercise, 95% offer medication administration, and 89% have experience with senior cats and cats with special needs. We know each cat is unique and may have specific care instructions. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.

Yes! Cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check before offering their services. You can also easily keep in touch with your cat sitter through messages on Rover for delightful photo updates. The Rover team is available 24/7, and your cat sitter has access to advice from qualified veterinary professionals. In the rare event of any issues during a booking, rest easy knowing your cat is covered by the Rover Guarantee reimbursement program for eligible veterinary care.

Note: If your cat sitter requested to cancel this booking, then they need to cancel from their account. Please contact them via Rover Messages.

We get it—sometimes plans change and you may need to cancel your cat sitting service. You can cancel an upcoming booking directly from the Rover app or your computer, in accordance with your cat sitter’s cancellation policy.