Cat Sitting in Holtsville

Book a cat sitter to stop by your home to feed and play with your cat.

End
Search

Every sitter passes an enhanced background check. Learn about RoverProtect

Top rated Holtsville cat sitters

Prices are estimates per visit. Pricing may vary based on your search. A booking fee of 11% and taxes will apply.

1 / 1
Sitter Profile Image: Michelle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Michelle H.
Star Sitter
from
$22
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
58 reviews
23 repeat clients
20 years of experience
Bohemia, NY, 11716

Michele was very attentive to my cat's needs, and did a wonderful job of making my pet feel comfortable and cared for on a simple check in visit. I would definitely rebook.

Profile image
Brendan W.
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa & Michael W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Lisa & Michael W.
Star Sitter
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
229 reviews
93 repeat clients
40 years of experience
East patchogue, NY, 11772

Absolutely wonderful! The care and attention Lisa and Michael pay to our kitties is a peace of mind 😻 And they will go the extra mile to make sure we return to a happy home. Thank you!

Profile image
Sharon P.
Sitter Profile Image: Daniela G.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Daniela G.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
85 reviews
24 repeat clients
10 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

My kittens were happy and healthy when I got home and all the used food bowls were clean. It was a pleasure to come back with everything in order!!

Profile image
Aline S.
Sitter Profile Image: Amber O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amber O.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
39 reviews
10 repeat clients
15 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

We left our 5 month old kitten with Amber and he had the time of his life. Amber is so caring and wonderful. She kept us updated every day on how he was doing, sent us lots of photos and videos. If you want a great pet sitter, Amber is definitely it!!

Profile image
Linda L.
Sitter Profile Image: Victoria M.
Verified Background Check
Victoria M.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
157 reviews
46 repeat clients
15 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

Another great review for Victoria! She has taken care of our cat many times for us now - medicating her twice a day, and sending the sweetest photos! We always know that we are leaving her in good hands when Victoria is taking care of her! 🤍

Profile image
Fleur J.
Sitter Profile Image: Madison R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Madison R.
Star Sitter
from
$22
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
31 reviews
9 repeat clients
14 years of experience
Holtsville, NY, 11742

I had never had a Pet Sitter before and I picked Madison to be the first one and I never could’ve chosen a better Pet Sitter! She took wonderful care of my cat family and they are my family. They’re my kids. I have four of them she showed up every day that I asked her too. She took care of the kids so wonderfully. I can’t even begin to tell you it was awesome! I would recommend Madison as a pet sitter to anybody and I can’t wait till my next trip because I will be requesting if she is free for her to watch my kittens again! She took wonderful care of them. She bought in a box for me that was delivered. I didn’t even know it was going to come and she had no problem with that she showed up on time stayed as long as she was supposed to played with the cat. Send me pictures of playing with the cats and cats are your family. That’s really really important! I have no children. They are my children and she watched my children perfectly thank you Madison!

Profile image
Donna C.
Sitter Profile Image: Donna M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Donna M.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
68 reviews
22 repeat clients
25 years of experience
Holtsville, NY, 11742

Donna was amazing! She truly cares about your pet and is dedicated to giving them the best care possible when you can't be with them. Will definitely use her again

Profile image
Kristin M.
Sitter Profile Image: Kerry W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kerry W.
Star Sitter
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
33 reviews
10 repeat clients
4 years of experience
Holbrook, NY, 11741

I found Kerry on Rover app after reading all her positive reviews and she responded to my request right away to provide in home care for my senior kitty. She was a great communicator an gave me updates and pictures during her 3 evenings with Samson. She came over to do a meet n greet and she met Samson n watched the treats he gets slong with food n watet and she had to maneuver a door code and alarm code n handled everything with ease. We have a steady sitter for the dog but not Samson. I'm very happy that I now have a cat sitter for Samson. I highly recommend Kerry 's Services for your pets needs.

Profile image
Christa S.
Sitter Profile Image: Christiana F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Christiana F.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
10 reviews
3 repeat clients
4 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

Christiana was great. She took care of my cat Domino for a week and when I returned he was well fed and well scooped. She kept everything in order and the house and litter box was clean when I got back. I was given good feedback after every visit and she arrived exactly when she was supposed to. Highly recommended!

Profile image
Bruce S.
Sitter Profile Image: Amanda M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amanda M.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
11 reviews
1 repeat client
15 years of experience
Farmingville, NY, 11738

Amanda was amazing with our dogs and bunny. Dogs were very comfortable with her and were very happy to see her each drop in . She was very attentive and detailed in each drop in and kept in touch throughout the whole week. I would highly recommend using her for any of your pets needs

Profile image
Mike R.
Sitter Profile Image: Staci G.
Verified Background Check
Staci G.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
31 reviews
7 repeat clients
30 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

As always, Staci was on time (even a little early) and took great care of Molly. She sat on the floor and played with her, made sure she also did all of her potty stuff, and gave her treats for being a good girl. Staci definitely loves what she does, and enjoys being of service! Will book again!

Profile image
Michelle H.
Sitter Profile Image: Tricia L.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Tricia L.
from
$27
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
454 reviews
17 repeat clients
20 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

Tricia was wonderful with our 2 cats. We were away for a weekend for our daughter’s wedding so we needed someone that would care for them like we would. Tricia did that & more. It was wonderful to not have to worry about our fur babies while we were celebrating our human baby. Thank you Tricia!

Profile image
Nicole P.
Sitter Profile Image: Cynthia A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Cynthia A.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
21 reviews
11 repeat clients
59 years of experience
Farmingville, NY, 11738

My partner and I were so happy with Cynthia! We were so happy with how great she was with our fur babies Augie and Mona and the fact that she was able to help us out last minute was AMAZING!!! Very thorough and paid attention to detail! We will definitely have Cynthia watch our babies again!

Profile image
america p.
Sitter Profile Image: Brianna & Steven F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Brianna & Steven F.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
3 reviews
2 repeat clients
25 years of experience
Holbrook, NY, 11741

About: I have taken care of pets all my life from dogs to cats to bunnies to snakes and bearded dragons. Myself and my husband Steve would work together in caring for your fur babies. I work as a nurse and I work mostly weekends and my husband is home all weekend. We used to foster puppies for various shelters but decided to take a break for the summer and are looking to make your dogs feel at home. We can only take in dog friendly and kid friendly dogs as we also have 2 dogs and a 3 year old. We have a fenced in yard and go on frequent walks and would love for our dog Remy to have another friend to play with! I work mostly weekends and my husband is home all weekend so your fur babies won’t be alone. We also have 2 children that love to help with the dogs. I have a fenced in yard and two friendly dogs. My one dog, Remy, is high energy and loves to play. My other dog, Shiba, is old and just sleeps all day so Remy would love to have a playmate. We do not crate our dogs but can crate yours if that’s what your dog is used to.

Sitter Profile Image: chelsea s.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
chelsea s.
from
$23
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
2 reviews
15 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

Chelsea was such a great care taker of my 2 outdoor cats. She met with us before our booking. She even took care of a package while were away. Pictures were sent every day. Thank you Chelsea.

Profile image
Jennifer
Sitter Profile Image: Linda L.
Verified Background Check
Linda L.
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
29 reviews
7 repeat clients
19 years of experience
Holbrook, NY, 11741

Great sitter. She watched our two cats while we were out of the Country and it was amazing to know they were so well taken care of. We will definitely ask for her again!

Profile image
Giovanna B.
Sitter Profile Image: Michala S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Michala S.
from
$17
per visit
10 years of experience
Farmingville, NY, 11738

About: What Sets Me Apart: I treat every pet like family — with patience, consistency, and plenty of love. I know how important it is to have someone you can truly rely on, so communication and trust are always my top priorities. I send detailed updates and photos every visit, so you never have to wonder how your pet is doing. Whether your furry friend needs long walks, belly rubs, or just a calm presence while you’re away, I make sure they feel safe, happy, and cared for. I’m responsible, punctual, and treat your home with the same respect I give your pets. Your pets won’t just get care — they’ll get genuine companionship. Pet care is a happy part of my everyday life! I plan my schedule around my visits and walks, so each pet gets the time and attention they deserve. Whether it’s morning walks before work, midday check-ins, or cozy evening visits, I make sure their routines stay consistent and stress-free. On weekends, I have extra flexibility for longer stays, house sitting, or extra playtime in the yard or on walks. Caring for animals isn’t something I squeeze in — it’s something I look forward to every day. Whether your pet stays with me or I come to you, my goal is always the same — to make them feel comfortable, safe, and loved. When pets stay in my home, I keep their routines as close to normal as possible — regular feeding times, plenty of walks, play, and affection. I make sure they have cozy spots to relax and never feel alone or stressed. When I’m caring for pets in your home, I treat your space with respect and follow all your instructions carefully — from feeding schedules to favorite toys and walking routes. I send regular updates and photos, so you always know how your furry family member is doing. Every pet is unique, so I adjust my care to match their personality and comfort level — whether they’re playful and energetic or prefer calm companionship.

Sitter Profile Image: Maureen M.
Verified Background Check
Maureen M.
from
$16
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
13 reviews
5 repeat clients
3 years of experience
Farmingville, NY, 11738

I will definitely use Maureen for my next trip. She’s Very sweet and kind. Made my trip unstressed knowing she was taking care of my cat Gizmo.

Profile image
Tara C.
Sitter Profile Image: Asia S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Asia S.
from
$18
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
2 reviews
11 years of experience
holtsville, NY, 11742

Asia was great! She dropped-in on my doggie Dunkin’ while I was at work. She let me know how he did and sent pictures. I recommend Asia and I will ask her to see Dunkin’ again soon.

Profile image
Lindsay & Matthew R.
Sitter Profile Image: Rachel S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Rachel S.
from
$20
per visit
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
5 reviews
15 years of experience
Holtsville, NY, 11742

Rachel was fantastic. She was very attentive to our pups and sent pictures of them for us to see. She did everything we asked her to do with ease and confidence. We highly recommend Rachel for all your pet care needs and will definitely be using her again.

Profile image
Stephanie M.
1 / 1
View more sitters

Over 16
pet parents in Holtsville have booked cat sitting

Holtsville cat parents share their Rover experiences

1 / 1
5.0 out of 5.0 stars

I had never had a Pet Sitter before and I picked Madison to be the first one and I never could’ve chosen a better Pet Sitter! She took wonderful care of my cat family and they are my family. They’re my kids. I have four of them she showed up every day that I asked her too. She took care of the kids so wonderfully. I can’t even begin to tell you it was awesome! I would recommend Madison as a pet sitter to anybody and I can’t wait till my next trip because I will be requesting if she is free for her to watch my kittens again! She took wonderful care of them. She bought in a box for me that was delivered. I didn’t even know it was going to come and she had no problem with that she showed up on time stayed as long as she was supposed to played with the cat. Send me pictures of playing with the cats and cats are your family. That’s really really important! I have no children. They are my children and she watched my children perfectly thank you Madison!

Profile image
Donna C.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5.0 stars

My kittens were happy and healthy when I got home and all the used food bowls were clean. It was a pleasure to come back with everything in order!!

Profile image
Aline S.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5.0 stars

I was extremely happy with Kerry pet sitting for me. She was punctual, caring and loving to my two little dogs and my cat. She took wonderful care of them and went above and beyond by cleaning up after them and caring about my home as well. I highly recommend Kerry and will be using her fantastic services again!

Profile image
Joanne C.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5.0 stars

Amanda was very communicative and took great, loving care of my two kitties. Highly recommended and would book again.

Profile image
Aaron H.
Drop-In Visits
5.0 out of 5.0 stars

Kelly is the cat whisperer (for dogs too!!) My 7 month of age ‘Cornish Rex” Luna loved Kelly for knowing everything about kitten/cat life. She provided play time, kitty meal time, along width affection. And during Luna rest time her liter boxes and dishes were cleaned. Kelly also advised me regarding a skin care question I had about Luna too. She is very professional, reliable and experienced with dog/puppy care too. I highly recommend her with confidence.

Profile image
Karen C.
Drop-In Visits
1 / 1
Find pet care near you

How Rover works

  1. 1. Search

    Read verified reviews by cat parents like you and choose a sitter who’s a great match for you and your cat
  2. 2. Meet & Greet

    Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your cat while you’re away
  3. 3. Book & Pay

    All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!

The median cost per night for cat sitting in Holtsville is $25

Why Choose Rover?

  • Cashless payments

    Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.

  • Reservation protection

    It doesn’t happen often, but if your cat sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.

  • World-class support

    We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total cat fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.

Sitters in Holtsville average 5
repeat cat sitting clients

Cat Sitting FAQs

Frequently asked questions about Rover