Cat Sitting Cumberland

“Janis is the only one I call to take care of my kitties and they all really like her! She comes when she is supposed to, feeds and scoops litter just like she is supposed to!”

Haley W.

“Kristina has watched my cat twice now and has done a great job! She is attentive to detail and takes great care of him! I can trust her when I’m gone, and that means so much!”

Madeline P.

About: I've had dogs since I was born and throughout my entire life. I've had puppies, senior dogs, and all big dogs! I've been sitting for neighbors and friends for years, too. I love to play inside or outside. My specialty is cuddling the love bugs. I'm currently working a very flexible part time job and I have a reliable vehicle, so pet care fits very easily into my day! I keep a close eye on all the pets (mostly because I'm trying to get them to hang out with me). I set reminders and have notes to keep on top of things and never forget a step! I am very attentive to my surroundings when I am sitting so I can keep the love bugs safe and comfortable.

“Second time we have used Mindy for our boys. Another amazing job. I cannot recommend Mindy enough. Even the anti-social one was able to come around and participate after a few days of coaxing. The two social ones clearly looked forward to her visits. Again, I cannot recommend her enough!”

Derek J.

“3rd time I’ve had Natalie come Catsit and I always come home to a happy cat! She takes great photos and notes, so glad I found a reliable pet sitter in Indy!”

Mychaela C.

“We’ve booked Samantha three times in the last two years. We know we can trust our kitties in Samantha’s care and experience. She’s a tremendous support and resource and hope to continue using her services for many more years.”

Rachel K.

“Ross was very attentive during our meet and greet. Thomas seemed happy upon my return!”

Tonya C.

“Kristina is phenomenal and is great with our cat. He doesn’t warm up to most people, but he lives Kristina. She is prompt and always communicates thoroughly. I was out of town and expecting an important package, and she went above and beyond to look behind the house each day to make sure it wasn’t left out back. After a couple of days she asked if she should check the mailbox and to my astonishment, there it was. I highly recommend Kristina for pet care needs.”

Mike F.

“Laura was great! She was easy to communicate with and took good care of our cats while we were on a trip. :) I would definitely use her services again!”

Haley C.

“Kylie did. Great job looking after our shy kitties for 10 days. Knew just how to approach them so one even came out to socialize ! We were very happy knowing they were being so well cared for.”

Eileen B.

“Michelle was awesome! Took very good care of Louie! Highly recommend for your pet sitting needs.”

Richard B.

About: I work from home Monday - Friday so your lovable friend will be consistently monitored, I have a two story home with three bedrooms however it’s just my husband and I with our three cats so lots of space, I also have a fenced in backyard and live in a walkable neighborhood in Cumberland Indiana if your pet needs to be walked. ☺️ I’ve had several years of hands-on experience caring for cats with a wide range of personalities, including shy, independent, high-energy, and more strong-willed (‘spicy’) temperaments. My experience comes from raising and caring for my own three cats, each with very different needs and behaviors. I’ve worked closely with rescue cats and understand the patience and consistency required to help them feel safe and comfortable in a new environment. I’m very attentive to body language and behavioral cues, which allows me to adjust my care style to each pet’s comfort level. In my home, I provide a calm, structured, and low-stress environment. I have the ability to separate pets if needed, making it ideal for animals who are shy, anxious, or prefer their own space. I prioritize cleanliness, routine, and safety at all times. I work from home full-time, which allows me to provide consistent, attentive care for pets throughout the day. I have several automatic feeders and scheduled wet food times, along with fresh water bowls, so meals are always on time. My husband also comes home at the same time each day, providing extra hands and supervision to ensure pets feel safe and attended to. Our home has a predictable routine, which helps cats feel comfortable and secure. I’m able to adjust playtime, attention, or quiet time to match each pet’s personality, whether they prefer independent relaxation or interactive enrichment. My home is a calm, secure space for pets, located in a safe neighborhood. It’s just my husband, our three cats, and me—no kids—so the environment is quiet and low-traffic. I have multiple rooms available to help cats adjust comfortably, so shy or independent pets can have their own space, while those who enjoy company can stay nearby in my home office while I work. Caring for my own three cats gives me firsthand experience with multi-cat dynamics, and I know how to manage interactions to ensure all pets feel safe and stress-free. I maintain a clean, structured environment with consistent routines, monitored feeding and hydration, and lots of attention to comfort and enrichment. Whether your pet needs quiet personal space or friendly companionship, I tailor their care to make sure they feel safe, happy, and well-cared for while you’re away.

About: I was a Rover caregiver for several years, then I adopted a rescue who is reactive to other dogs and had to stop boarding/sitting. I missed interacting with all the great pets I met, so I'm back in action for drop-in visits and walks on weekends. I've been caring for friends' and family pets for almost 30 years. I'm typically very good with anxious/shy dogs, and I'm not squeamish about dogs who give lots of slobbery kisses LOL I work full-time Monday through Friday, so I'm available for drop-in visits and walks on the weekends or on holidays when I have the day off from work. When doing walks or drop-in visits, I follow my clients' instructions, and have no problems with feeding or administering medications. I also let your pets set the pace and give them space & time needed to get used to me being in their space.

“Trinity was reliable and timely with her visits and ensured our outside cat was fed and watered while we were away. We won’t hesitate to use her services again when we’re away.”

Rick M.

“Amanda was incredible! She came and hung out with my cat and sent me multiple photos each time she came. She even came to check on him after a storm to see if he was okay. I would definitely book with her again.”

Trisha M.

“My cat, Foster, is very needy and any little thing upsets him so I decided to schedule a house sitter rather than drop-in visits. Malika was great, sending pictures and making sure both Foster and I were okay. :-) I will be sure to reach out to her again when I travel!”

Kelly C.

“Alexandria was very attentive to my pets and provided great care. She was also very easy to communicate with and she ensured she followed the directions I left for her. I felt comfortable knowing they were in good hands while I was away.”

Janis W.

“I love knowing I can count on Kort to give my sweet girl all the love and attention she needs while I am away! He always goes above and beyond to ensure both she and my home are well taken care of. If there is any type of schedule change or unexpected event, he's quick to outreach and communicate with me for resolution. Can't recommend Kort enough!”

Crystal B.

“Brooklyn and Taylor took excellent care for our babies! Thank you so much!”

Krista S.

About: I’ve taken care of dogs and cats since I was little. I am never aggressive with animals but I am strong and athletic if you’re pet has a lot of energy. I currently work as a personal trainer so my hours are flexible depending on when I have clients. My schedule is more open than usual right now. I always make sure the pets have fresh water and are able to enjoy their walks as their time. I understand the importance of being consistent with pets so I always keep up with the owners specific preferences.