Pet Sitting in Shelter Island

“We were delighted with Anica. She sent pics and videos and gave our sweet tomcat the best attention. We would love for Anica to look after our boy again when we are off on future travels! Thank you Anica! Marianne H.”

Marianne H H.

About: I had a dog in my family for around 10 years. He was really the best. It was so fun to watch him grow up and take care of him through it all. I absolutely adore animals and love to give them attention, play with them and learn with them. I work full time but have different hours and sometimes will be available in the mornings, sometimes the middle of the day, and sometimes weekends! I will always have time for animals. I provide a safe and comforting environment for dogs and humans alike. I am very considerate and observant of everything around me so I will always make sure everyone is safe and having a great time with everything they need. I am very respectful of people’s space and always make sure to leave things the way I found them.

About: I have a deep love for dogs and 25 years of experience caring for them. I can assist with training, administer medications as needed, and ensure your pet receives plenty of exercise, attention, and loving care. "As a work-from-home professional, I have ample time and a genuine love for animals. I offer a variety of pet care services, including boarding, home sitting, daycare, walks, and playtime, available on both weekdays and weekends." I'm flexible and can adapt to your dog's specific care needs. To ensure a safe environment for all, dogs will remain on a leash on my 3-acre property unless they are exceptionally well-trained off-leash. Please let me know if you'd like to include walks on Bay Beach, the beach, or at a dog run in your dog's care plan.

“Brenda was absolutely amazing! I needed a last minute sitter for two dogs, and she was incredibly responsive and communicative before, during, and after the visit. She followed all instructions carefully, sent plenty of updates and photos, and made me feel totally at ease. I would definitely book with her again!”

Batya Z.

“I’m so happy to have found Lacina in the sea of prospects! From the very first meeting, my dog Cub, who’s usually shy around strangers, immediately warmed up to her. It was clear right away that she has a natural connection with animals. Dogs know good people, and Lacina is definitely one of them! We both absolutely love her, and I’m so grateful to have found someone so trustworthy and kind.”

Lorraine R.

“Rachel took great care of our cat while we were away!”

Laura M.

“Jane was great with our dogs. Extremely reliable. Sent photos of both of them. This was our first time using Rover and we are quite happy. Would recommend Jane to All pet owners.”

Laura M.

“Great experience! When our friends decided to come to the city last minute, Deb responded right away to meet up with us. Our dog and cat liked Deb immediately, and her visits throughout the day were well communicated and all went smoothly. We were able to relax and enjoy our day —so thankful for Deb!”

Anne G.

About: I grew up taking care of my two medium/big family dogs. Then my siblings made me a dog aunt of four small-big. I love and help with all. I am currently working fully remote. My schedule is extremely flexible. Each day is different, but I have a lot of free time to go on walks and play. I live in an apartment with a large balcony. We have a dog park and Mutts next door. As for your home if you give me instructions, I follow them.

“Jade did an exceptional job caring for our beloved 13-year-old Siamese cat. We entrusted her with his care for two days, and upon our return, he was completely content and unfazed by our absence—a true testament to Jade’s attentiveness and care. If you're looking for a reliable pet sitter, you can trust that your pet will be in great hands with Jade. We couldn’t be happier with her service!”

Julie S.

About: I have grown up with a dog in my household my whole life! I have experience with everything from laid back Golden’s to high strung Sheppards! Dogs give me so much happiness and I can’t wait to make local dogs happy too! I can do anything from run with your dog to just hang out with them on the couch. Whatever you need I can be more then accommodating! I work 9-5 Monday-Friday. I’m available after work and on weekends as well! I’m all about getting your dog outside and being active. I think it’s important for them to get fresh air, sniff around and get all they’re bottled up energy out! I can’t wait to meet you and your fantastic furry friend! I’m currently working Monday-Friday, 9am-5pm. I’m available after work and on weekends. I’m available for dog walks, drop ins and can take care of a dog at the owners home. I will not be caring for dogs in my home but I am happy to come to your home and take care of your dog or cat.

About: I offer a refined blend of reliability, attentiveness, and genuine care. Every walk is more than a routine. It’s a tailored experience designed to enrich and soothe, with most outings heading to the beach for a serene and invigorating escape from the ordinary. I treat your dog with the same devotion and discretion I would my own, ensuring every visit delivers consistency, comfort, and peace of mind. With a flexible, work-from-home schedule, I’m readily available to accommodate pets with special needs or those who thrive on constant attention. My secure, fenced-in yard provides ample space for play, making your pet’s time here feel like a true retreat. For pet care that feels personal, professional, and luxurious—this is where trust and comfort mee Pet care is woven into my schedule with designated morning, midday, and early-evening blocks reserved exclusively for walks, feedings, and enrichment activities. Because I work from home, I can readily adjust meetings around each pet’s needs while maintaining real-time monitoring and frequent wellness checks. This structure ensures consistent, attentive care without compromising professional commitments. I offer a secure, fenced yard that provides ample space for safe play and exercise. Additionally, being just a short walk from the beach, most outings become scenic and enriching experiences—offering a refreshing alternative to the standard neighborhood stroll.

“Rebecca was amazing with my dog, Buddy. She knew just what to do with him.”

J D.

About: I’ve been taking care/training dogs of all breeds for years now. I just love pets and spending time with them! I’m looking forward to hanging out with anyone’s pets. :) I am currently working part time and I own my own business, I’m very open so I will be able to take care of your pet anytime you need. I have a fenced yard and I have a friendly labradoodle perfect environment for other dogs . My neighborhood is very relaxed and would love to have another furry friend around! :)

“Reliable! She is so nice, we liked her immediately!”

Elizabeth P.

“Jess dropped in to take care of our dogs for us. Both pups were fed and happy when we got home! We will definitely book with her again!”

Larry S.

About: I have taken care of every kind of pet since I was 8. I raised animals born in my household from dogs, cats, birds, rabbits and horses and nurtured them . I am currently working from home part of the time . Extra pet care is a welcome and uplifting part of my day ! Your pets will receive lots of love and affection from me . I have a cat and a rabbit at home and each has their own room . They have a peaceful environment to rest, play and eat in and get a lot of quality petting and fun time .

About: I have had and cared for all kinds of animals my entire life. I have 15+ years of experience in pet sitting from cats to horses and most animals in between! I am available for house sitting and care daily! I usually take my own dogs on long walks or to the beach and would be happy to do the same with your pup! I have two friendly dogs to keep your pup company! I have the ability to crate your dog or put them in a gated room if needed.

About: My love being outdoors and my athleticism translate perfectly to being a good dog walker. I enjoy spending time outside with the dogs, ensuring they get plenty of exercise and fresh air. I can handle energetic dogs and keep up with their pace, making walks enjoyable and beneficial for them. This combination of passion and physical fitness ensures that the dogs in my care will be happy, healthy, and well-exercised. I am a dedicated law school student with a passion for pets. Balancing my rigorous academic schedule, I find joy in walking and caring for dogs. My commitment to detail and responsibility, helps me provide your dog with the best care. Whether it's a quick walk or an extended adventure, I'm here to keep your dog happy and healthy. I have classes Monday - Thursday but am available after 5pm, on Friday and the weekends I have more availability! Please feel free to request a walk anytime and I can see if I can accommodate it. While walking the dogs I will be mindful of other animals/ traffic on the street, allow the dog regular breaks if they seem tired and pay attention to the dogs behavior to keep them happy and motivated.

About: I have taken care of my pets and others pets, ever since I was a child. While most teenagers were babysitting, I was pet sitting. Since I have such a love for animals, I then started working in an emergency vet office, and eventually received my dog training certificate! I work from home therefore I am available most of the day! My hours are flexible and would be able to work around most schedules. I would prefer to pet sit at the owners home, since this is where pets are most comfortable. Who knows, a nice dog park could be in order!!