Cat Sitting in Fire Island
Book a cat sitter to stop by your home to feed and play with your cat.
More resources
A focus on safety
Enjoy photo updates, easy messaging, and the knowledge that every sitter joining Rover needs to pass an enhanced background check. Learn more about RoverProtect
Top rated Fire Island cat sitters
“This was my first time using Rover and I was very happy with Ericka. Our cat was very comfortable around her. I will definitely use her again when I need a sitter. 5 stars!!”
“I'm thankful for the reliable and friendly service. Kaileigh followed all the instructions I provided and made sure my cat was well-fed and comfortable during my absence.”
“Sandy is sincere, honest and competent. We hired Sandy to take care of our two cats for a little over 2 weeks. When she came for her first visit, we realized that we had forgotten to put in our initial request that we also have two outdoor cats we care for & feed. We asked Sandy if she would be okay doing that while we were away and she graciously agreed. She spent enough time with us to make sure that she understood all our instructions. While we were away she came everyday at the same time for 30 minutes to be with our cats, freshened up their food & water bowls, cleaned their little box and left little treats for them so they got a little exercise. She sent us updates and pictures through the Rover App during every visit so we could see our fur-babies were happy and healthy. We had peace of mind while on vacation that she was caring for our cats. We will definitely hire her again to take care of our cats when we travel next.”
“Staff was a fantastic sitter and took great care of our two sphinx cats while we were on vacation. She kept in continual contact, administered medications when they were required, and spent extra time with our cats. It is clear that Steff enjoys the company of pets. She was punctual and went the extra mile when our plans were changed at short notice and beyond our control. We cannot recommend Steff highly enough.”
About: I work with dogs at a kennel and walk dogs everyday that I’m there. I am determined and hard working as well. I want to make sure you and your dog are happy. I’ve been working at a dog kennel for almost 2 years, and I have a lot of experience with walking dogs. I’m working full time at the kennel currently, and I walk a lot of dogs throughout each day. Dog walking has became something that is a part of my daily routine. I have a lot of pets at home, and I work with dogs as well. I know how to properly walk a dog to make sure they are safe.
“Brianna is great! She came for a drop in to let our dogs out & to feed them. She followed all of our instructions, and the dogs were happy to see her! She came for a introductory visit before I booked her, and I can tell she loves animals. Looking forward to our next visit! Thanks again!”
About: I have taken care of pets since I was 5 years old. That includes dogs, cats, lizards, snakes. I love them all. They love me. I can cover most days and evening needs. I have the needed transportation to meet your needs. I am ready to help you any way I can. I can care for your pets needs in your home or my apartment. I am flexible in doing whatever is required to meet your needs
About: I’m here to help when you just don’t have the time to do it all! Services include: -Pet sitting for cats and dogs in the comfort of your own home -Feeding, daily visits -scoop litter boxes -play with pets I absolutely love animals and will treat your pets like they are my own. I have lots of experience with senior and special needs dogs & cats! I am a full time pet sitter who has open availability starting Feb 1st 2025. I am new to this area but I have had my pet sitting business for 5 years in Marietta GA. I care for your pets in the comfort of your own home. I offer 30 minutes to overnight visits. There is a 30 minute minimum for cats and a 60 minute minimum for dogs. I treat your pets like they are my own, with plenty of love!
About: From fish and frogs and hamsters to dogs and cats I have had and also taken care of many different animals. I had a yellow lab growing up for 17 years and she was mine and my family’s whole world. Now I spend my time taking care of friends pets when they are away and my neighbors two adorable cats. One of which was adopted as an outdoor stray so he sometimes comes over to my house for some food, belly rubs, and a nap. I was always the go to person for my neighbors for pet sitting and I hope to expand my services and love for animals to a wider range. I work as a chemistry teacher and do not currently have a Summer job so my availability is flexible. There are times where I may have other obligations so clear and advanced communication is greatly appreciated! I am available to visit 1-4 times a day and happy to go for walks twice a day. I will typically visit morning/early afternoon to later afternoon/early evening. But I can stop by at different times if needed such as for specific feeding or medicine times. From past experience I know that every animal is different in both personality and needs. Whether that is feeding at certain times, certain food preparation, or just having a calm demeanor. Just like being a teacher, I am accommodating and would love to provide proper care for each individual animals needs. I also check and double check any directions and will make sure to provide the care that your pet needs.
About: I’ve owned my late dog Rudy for 20 years. My neighbors have relied on me before to pet sit & walk their dogs! As old as Rudy’s lived to be he has required medication, and I have always been able to administer these to him as needed. I also have experience with active dogs; I currently own a 4 year old German Shepherd! I’m working full time with a flexible schedule! I work a 4 day work week and so can be completely available Saturday, Sunday, or Mondays (and am able to alternate Mondays and Fridays depending on the amount of notice I am provided). While I do offer stay-overs, at this point in time if you would like for me to do a stay-over, please note that I will need my dog to come as he has no other caretaker. He is crated when I am not in home (I will bring my own crate). He also eats in his crate. I would like for our dogs to also be able to meet to see how they interact prior to the stay! Important: He is not neutered. Lots of love and attention, plenty of walks and grooming, and my dog is always fed on schedule! Whatever you need, I can do—just let me know your own preferences for your pooch!
About: I have always lived with pets, including dogs and cats. I am responsible for walking, feeding, and taking out dogs of all sizes. I love to make animals feel loved, youthful, and happy. I’m currently a full time student during the fall and spring. I work part-time in the summer. I am available most nights of the summer and some days. I am willing to run around with wild pets, or comfort older/anxious dogs. I can bring toys for your dog to play with and treats for them to enjoy.
About: I’ve been taking care of and been around pets since I was a little kid I love animals with a passion and would love to meet your furry friends!! Always had a passion for animals and will take really amazing care of them!! I work part time during the week and am available from Thursday - Sunday and can sometimes make an exception for other days of the week just depends on my schedule! But I’d have plenty of time to fit it potty breaks for your animals and feeding them and playing with them keeping them entertained!! As a dedicated pet sitter, I provide personalized care tailored to your pet’s needs. I’ll ensure they receive regular meals, fresh water, and plenty of exercise. Walks, playtime, and companionship are my priority to keep them happy and stress-free. I’ll follow any special instructions, including medications, grooming, or training routines. For overnight stays, I’ll maintain their usual schedule to provide comfort and security. Your home will also be well cared for, with mail collection, plant watering, and security checks. I’ll send daily updates with photos, so you have peace of mind while you’re away. Your pet’s happiness is my goal!
About: I’ve potty trained a puppy. I’ve taken care of three dogs at once, all different ages and needs, from puppy to senior pup. I’ve rescued my feral cat and now it’s a house cat! I am currently looking to get more exercise into my daily routine and no better way than by walking a lovely pup. I’m available on weekdays 4pm- on. Weekends I’m flexible with availability. I have a fenced in yard. I can crate pets. Full attention and supervision will be given to the pet. I will read given instructions carefully and thoroughly.
Loving cat sitters in your neighborhood
Search Results
Lisa & Michael W.Star Sitter
“Excellent service every time, they really do go above and beyond to take care of our cat and fish! We feel confident and comfortable with their care”
Michelle H.Star Sitter
“Michelle did an excellent job, even finding Miss Molly in her hiding place! Miss Molly and I look forward to working with Michelle again! Thank you!”
Ericka R.Star Sitter
“This was my first time using Rover and I was very happy with Ericka. Our cat was very comfortable around her. I will definitely use her again when I need a sitter. 5 stars!!”
Amber O.Star Sitter
“She has been doing an excellent job keeping me informed every day and sending me pictures I highly recommend amber and will be using her in the future”
Joanne B.
“Wonderful! Thank you so much! I was hesitant to use an app to take care of Heidi but I couldn't have asked for better care. I (and Heidi) look forward to future visits. Thanks!”
Samantha S.
“Great job! Very responsible and caring. Thank you Samantha!!”
Kaileigh H.Star Sitter
“I'm thankful for the reliable and friendly service. Kaileigh followed all the instructions I provided and made sure my cat was well-fed and comfortable during my absence.”
Sandy K.
Star Sitter
“Sandy is sincere, honest and competent. We hired Sandy to take care of our two cats for a little over 2 weeks. When she came for her first visit, we realized that we had forgotten to put in our initial request that we also have two outdoor cats we care for & feed. We asked Sandy if she would be okay doing that while we were away and she graciously agreed. She spent enough time with us to make sure that she understood all our instructions. While we were away she came everyday at the same time for 30 minutes to be with our cats, freshened up their food & water bowls, cleaned their little box and left little treats for them so they got a little exercise. She sent us updates and pictures through the Rover App during every visit so we could see our fur-babies were happy and healthy. We had peace of mind while on vacation that she was caring for our cats. We will definitely hire her again to take care of our cats when we travel next.”
Marianna D.
“Kept in touch, took pictures and did everything we asked for the kitties! :)”
Steff S.
“Staff was a fantastic sitter and took great care of our two sphinx cats while we were on vacation. She kept in continual contact, administered medications when they were required, and spent extra time with our cats. It is clear that Steff enjoys the company of pets. She was punctual and went the extra mile when our plans were changed at short notice and beyond our control. We cannot recommend Steff highly enough.”
Christopher S.
“Chris is wonderful with pets. He has been walking my dogs for a few months. I know he also works at a dog kennel so he has a lot of experience with dogs. I highly recommend him to others.”
Brianna D.
“Brianna is great! She came for a drop in to let our dogs out & to feed them. She followed all of our instructions, and the dogs were happy to see her! She came for a introductory visit before I booked her, and I can tell she loves animals. Looking forward to our next visit! Thanks again!”
Nadine B.
“Thanks to Nadine I was able to go on vacation with peace of mind! A very caring person with a instant connection with my cat !”
Abby R.Star Sitter
“I have known Abby for many years now. She has been an excellent dog walker to both of my dogs Rio and Magic. The times she has walked my dogs she has been responsible and extremely caring. Both my dogs love Abby very much and this is why I always have her walk my dogs as much as possible.”
Heather L.
“Heather is the best pet sitter we have ever had! We have a lot of pets with a lot of personalities and needs, she is very mindful and attentive to each of them individually. We have left our 5 cats and big dog with her for both short overnighters and long 2+ week trips and we always come home to happy animals who are still comfortably within their routines. Our dog Bean loves Heather and our finicky cats warmed up to her very quickly. We always felt safe and comfortable leaving our babies in her care!”
Danielle W.
“Danielle is extremely loving and nurturing towards animals. She has accompanied myself in dog sitting for my family members, and as someone who has not grown up with pets it was extremely helpful having her with me, as she knew a lot more about how to care for and interact with pets than I did. Having her with me definitely made the experience easier for me, and I felt more confident that the next time I could do it myself because of what she taught me. She has also cared for stray cats in her neighborhood, including providing them with food and even taking one to the vet because its paw was inflamed. Danielle always wants to help animals and enjoys taking care of those who need it. While I myself do not have any pets, she would be my first choice to pet sit if i did; I would feel secure knowing she was there.”
Kirsten S.
“Kirsten has been such a blessing! We are very cautious and particular with who enters our home and takes care of our 2 fur babies (Bengal cats), but now as consistent clients we feel so at ease while she is taking care of them as she is extremely responsible and personable with them! My partner and I appreciate how trustworthy & reliable she is as we know our babies are safe with her. This puts our minds at ease and there’s zero stress when we are away. We also appreciate her enthusiasm and fun loving energy, as this puts my heart at ease knowing they enjoy her company and have fun with her! We no longer stress about going away or how our fur babies will be without us around- she’s that amazing!”
Christopher K.
About: I have always lived with pets, including dogs and cats. I am responsible for walking, feeding, and taking out dogs of all sizes. I love to make animals feel loved, youthful, and happy. I’m currently a full time student during the fall and spring. I work part-time in the summer. I am available most nights of the summer and some days. I am willing to run around with wild pets, or comfort older/anxious dogs. I can bring toys for your dog to play with and treats for them to enjoy.
Benjamin H.
About: I’ve been taking care of and been around pets since I was a little kid I love animals with a passion and would love to meet your furry friends!! Always had a passion for animals and will take really amazing care of them!! I work part time during the week and am available from Thursday - Sunday and can sometimes make an exception for other days of the week just depends on my schedule! But I’d have plenty of time to fit it potty breaks for your animals and feeding them and playing with them keeping them entertained!! As a dedicated pet sitter, I provide personalized care tailored to your pet’s needs. I’ll ensure they receive regular meals, fresh water, and plenty of exercise. Walks, playtime, and companionship are my priority to keep them happy and stress-free. I’ll follow any special instructions, including medications, grooming, or training routines. For overnight stays, I’ll maintain their usual schedule to provide comfort and security. Your home will also be well cared for, with mail collection, plant watering, and security checks. I’ll send daily updates with photos, so you have peace of mind while you’re away. Your pet’s happiness is my goal!
Carina A.
“I’ve known Carina for years and she has got to be the biggest pet lover I know. She is always stopping to pet random dogs on the street and talking with the owners. She has a dog, 2 cats, and a rabbit. She is always buying them fun new toys and food/treats.”
How Rover works
1. Search
Read verified reviews by cat parents like you and choose a sitter who’s a great match for you and your cat
2. Meet & Greet
Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your cat while you’re away
3. Book & Pay
All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!
Why Choose Rover?
Cashless payments
Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.
Reservation protection
It doesn’t happen often, but if your cat sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.
World-class support
We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total cat fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.
Cat Sitting FAQs
Frequently asked questions about Rover
Cat sitters on Rover are free to set their rates. The median cost to hire a cat sitter in Fire Island on Rover as of Jul 2025 was about $25 per night, after factoring in Rover’s service fees. A cat sitter’s rate may also change as you customize your booking to fit your and your cat’s needs.
As of Jul 2025, there are 334 cat sitters in Fire Island. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.
Rover makes it easy to reach out to multiple cat sitters about your booking. Typically, 83% of Fire Island cat sitters respond in under an hour.
Cat sitters in Fire Island have an average of 15 years of experience. Cat sitters with repeat customers have an average of 5 repeat clients. Experience can vary from cat sitter to cat sitter, but you can view reviews, years of experience, and number of repeat clients when you compare cat sitters in Fire Island.
Do you simply need someone to stop by and play, feed, and scoop? Fire Island cat sitters are happy to take care of your cat while you’re at work, on vacation, or unavailable for the day, even if all you need is a quick drop-in! Your cat sitter will stop by to feed, play with, and snuggle your cat as many times a day as you like. And the best part? Your cat gets to stay on their home turf.
There are 334 cat sitters in Fire Island on Rover, so you’re sure to find the perfect match for your cat! In Fire Island, 94% of cat sitters offer daily exercise, 95% offer medication administration, and 92% have experience with senior cats and cats with special needs. We know each cat is unique and may have specific care instructions. You can filter, sort, expand your radius, read reviews, and compare pricing to find the perfect cat sitter near you. As a reminder, cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check for you and your cat’s safety.
Yes! Cat sitters joining Rover must pass a background check before offering their services. You can also easily keep in touch with your cat sitter through messages on Rover for delightful photo updates. The Rover team is available 24/7, and your cat sitter has access to advice from qualified veterinary professionals. In the rare event of any issues during a booking, rest easy knowing your cat is covered by the Rover Guarantee reimbursement program for eligible veterinary care.
Note: If your cat sitter requested to cancel this booking, then they need to cancel from their account. Please contact them via Rover Messages.
We get it—sometimes plans change and you may need to cancel your cat sitting service. You can cancel an upcoming booking directly from the Rover app or your computer, in accordance with your cat sitter’s cancellation policy.
Connect anywhere with the Rover app
