Pet Sitting vs. Kennel Boarding: Which Does Your Dog Prefer?

• This post contains affiliate links. Read more here.
• Not a substitute for professional veterinary help.

You’re heading out of town for a few days, and your dog can’t come with you. Now comes the tough part: choosing the best care option while you’re away. Is dog boarding in a kennel environment better, or would your dog be more comfortable boarding at a pet sitter’s? What about staying at your own home?

In this article, we’ll break down the differences between boarding at a sitter’s house, kennel boarding, and pet sitting. We’ll explain what each typically involves, compare costs, and give tips on how to determine which setup is best for your dog’s personality and needs.

Comparing Traditional Kennels, In-Home Boarding & Pet Sitting

Dogs have different personalities, energy levels, and needs, and it’s important to consider them all when you’re deciding on boarding.

For example, dogs that do best with a steady routine or get stressed in busy environments often feel more comfortable with in-home boarding or having a pet sitter come stay with them. Social, high-energy dogs, on the other hand, may enjoy the communal aspect of traditional boarding.

This quick comparison table can help you weigh the pros and cons of each option.

In-Home Dog Boarding

In-home dog boarding means your dog stays in a professional pet sitter’s private home, which may or may not include other pets. Depending on the sitter, your dog may be crate-free and welcome to lounge in common living areas, just like at home.

Costs

It may come as a surprise that overnight boarding at a pet sitter’s home is usually more affordable than boarding at a kennel. Nightly rates typically range from $25 to $45, depending on the sitter’s experience and the number of other furry guests in the house.

Costs include all the extra care and attention, and you’ll typically only need to pay extra for services like pick-up or drop-off.

In-home boarding considerations for your dog

Before sending your dog to stay in someone else’s home, think about how they’ll handle a new environment and a daily routine with someone new.

• Dog age: Puppies and senior dogs often benefit from closer supervision, more frequent potty breaks, and a quieter home setting.
• Dog personality: Dogs who prefer more human time and a cozier environment tend to do well with in-home boarding. It’s also usually a better fit for special-needs dogs with specific medical or dietary requirements.
• Environment needs: If your dog hates being in a crate or confined to smaller spaces, they might prefer in-home boarding, where sitters typically offer access to large portions of the home.
• Frequency: This option provides more consistency for the times you have to be away, giving your dog a secondary familiar environment.
• Care routine: Care is typically more flexible and customized than a boarding kennel. However, your dog will also have to adjust to the sitter’s own household routine, which may also include other dogs or pets.
• Ask about: Will other dogs be present? What’s the sitter’s routine, and how long will your dog be home alone?

Kennel Dog Boarding

Traditional kennel boarding means your dog stays in a facility designed to care for multiple pets. Dogs typically have their own sleeping area and follow a daily schedule that includes meals, potty breaks, and playtime.

Many kennels offer add-ons like group play, one-on-one walks, training sessions, or webcams so you can check in while you’re away. There are usually several staff members on-site.

Costs

Kennel boarding is often affordable, usually falling right in the middle of costs—it’s a bit more than in-home boarding but less than a pet sitter coming to your house to take care of your pup.

The typical price is $40 to $50 per night, depending on location and amenities. Additional services like one-on-one walks or medication administration are often available for an extra fee.

Luxury boarding

Luxury dog boarding is a step up from traditional kennel boarding and comes with added amenities and costs. Also known as pet resorts, pet hotels, or pet BnBs, this type of care is characterized by special treatment and upgraded facilities.

You’ll typically see high-end, personalized care for dogs with features such as private rooms, close supervision, enrichment routines, and grooming services.

Kennel considerations for your dog

Before boarding your dog at a kennel, think about what your dog actually enjoys day-to-day, and how well they’ll handle a change in routine. Factors to consider include:

• Dog age: Younger adult dogs often adapt more easily to new places, while senior dogs may find the environment tiring or stressful.
• Dog personality: Social, confident, and outgoing dogs who are also crate-trained often adjust well to kennel life.
• Environment needs: Kennels can be loud and busy, which may overstimulate noise-sensitive, shy, or anxious dogs. Additionally, larger dogs might need more space, and more active dogs may need more exercise.
• Frequency: Dogs who go to daycare may do better at boarding in the same environment because they’re familiar with the care providers and other dogs.
• Care routine: Dogs typically follow the kennel’s schedule, though some facilities may be more flexible in accommodating your dog’s typical routine.
• What to ask: What vaccinations are mandatory, and how much one-on-one attention each dog receives outside of feeding and potty breaks.

Antonio_Diaz via iStock

Pet Sitting at Your Home

Pet house sitting is when someone comes to your home and stays overnight—and usually most of the day—with your pup. One of the biggest perks of this pet care is that your dog gets exclusive attention and can stay in their own home, allowing them to keep up their usual routine and help limit stress when you’re away.

Costs

Typically, booking a pet sitter to stay overnight at your house can cost anywhere from $40 to $75 or more per night. Holidays, weekends, special caretaking needs, and last-minute bookings can all increase the costs, too.

Home sitting considerations for your dog

Before booking a pet sitter to stay at your home, here are some things to consider to ensure this is the best care for your dog.

• Dog age: Puppies and seniors will often benefit the most from being in a home environment. Staying in your home versus at the pet sitter’s is the least disruptive.
• Dog personality: This caretaking option is also better suited for dogs with behavioral issues like reactivity and separation anxiety, since it allows them to follow their usual routine and maintain a predictable schedule.
• Environment needs: Your dog will be able to stay in the comfort of their own home. This allows seniors to stay in a familiar space that has the aids they need, like non-slip floors or pet ramps, and helps puppies better stick to their crate and potty training.
• Frequency: Having a sitter stay in your home with your dog is excellent for pet parents who travel frequently and want to keep their dogs’ lives relatively the same. It can also be a more cost-effective option when booking care for multiple dogs or pets.
• Care routine: Ideally, your pet sitter will be able to spend more time with your pup at your home so they can keep their mealtimes, potty breaks, and other daily habits the same.
• What to ask: What are the exact arrival and departure times? How much time during the day will the sitter spend at home? Do they have experience caring for dogs with special behavioral or medical needs?

When To Choose Pet Sitting vs Boarding

Choosing between boarding at a facility or caretaker’s home vs pet sitting in your own home will depend on your dog’s temperament, behavioral and medical needs, and your budget.

You may want to choose boarding if your dog is social and enjoys group play, is healthy and doesn’t need stricter supervision, or you want a more affordable caretaking option. On the other hand, you may want to hire a sitter to stay in your home if you have a dog with specific medical or behavioral needs or who needs to follow a specific care routine.

Regardless of which you choose, Rover makes it easy to find both in-home boarding and pet sitting in your area. Search for caretakers in your area, filtering for your needs—whether that’s a sitter who will make your pup their only client, constant care around the clock, or a fenced yard for mid-day romps.

Then send a message and schedule a Meet and Greet, so you can make sure you’ve found the best fit for you and your pup’s needs!