House Sitting in Baiting Hollow

Find a loving house sitter to watch over your pets and your home.

Search

More resources

A focus on safety

Enjoy photo updates, easy messaging, and the knowledge that every sitter joining Rover needs to pass an enhanced background check.Learn more about RoverProtect

Loving house sitters in your neighborhood

Search Results

Sitter Profile Image: Paula G.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Paula G.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

1. Paula G.

Unplugged & genuine pet care ❤️
Ridge, NY, 11961
6.9 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$43
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
10 reviews
1 repeat client
Profile image

Paula was excellent in keeping us updated with photos and messages, which gave us peace of mind. Paula is a warm and caring person who clearly loves animals. We appreciate her kindness, professionalism as well as her attentiveness!

Availability updated today
Confirmed availability for Memorial Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Kyle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Kyle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

2. Kyle H.

Dog, cat, and general animal lover
Calverton, NY, 11933
4.5 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$48
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
17 reviews
8 repeat clients
Profile image

Kyle is a great pet sitter, he was very conscientious of the animals needs and was great in the house. He kept me up to date and sent pictures and updates. My dogs loved him! I highly recommend.

Availability updated 89 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Paul T.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Paul T.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

3. Paul T.

I love animals!
Calverton, NY, 11933
2.4 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$35
per night
2 reviews

Paul has been a friend of mine for YEARS!! We have watched each other’s dogs (I say pups 🐶)… many times… Paul volunteers at local animal shelters, coaches, and has a WONDERFUL family… He is a “go to” person for anything and always has your back…and your pets!!! Feel free to reach out further for more information re: Paul…

Availability updated yesterday
Sitter Profile Image: Jessica M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Jessica M.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

4. Jessica M.

Star Sitter
Life long lover of all the animals!
Hampton Bays, NY, 11946
13.1 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$75
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
19 reviews
7 repeat clients
Profile image

Jess was great with our dogs- great communication and sent pictures. She kept us at ease while we were away and the dogs were in great hands!! We will be using her again!

Availability updated 21 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: James N.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: James N.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

5. James N.

Dog Lover with 40 years Experience
Manorville, NY, 11949
7.5 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$70
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
4 reviews
1 repeat client
Profile image

James was incredible with my spoiled weimaraner. He followed the routine my dog needs perfectly, was very professional, super reliable, and left my apartment clean after his stay. I would highly recommend!

Availability updated 11 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Alexandrea V.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Alexandrea V.
Verified Background Check

6. Alexandrea V.

Lifelong Animal Lover
Riverhead, NY, 11792
5.3 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$100
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
4 reviews
2 repeat clients

Alexandrea is highly recommended as pet/dog sitter. She loves all pets and enjoys spending time with them. She is very compassionate and animals respond to her and get excited when she enters a room. She has a big heart and goes above and beyond to make pets feel loved. She has watched my dog and two cats several times and they hate to see her leave.

Availability updated 18 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: ELICIA N.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: ELICIA N.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

7. ELICIA N.

Life Long Lover of Four Leg Friends
riverhead, NY, 11901
3.2 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$50
per night
45 years of experience

About: I have lived my entire life with pets. I have raised puppies, attended obedience training, and have cared for them at end of life. I've had Shih Tzus, Labs, Goldens, Boxers, and currently have an older Beagle/Bulldog who was a rescue. My family has always had a dog of some kind. I am retired from office work and aside from a couple hours in the mornings of self care, I am generally free of daily encumbrances I have been a pet sitter previously when I lived in NY. Both the Stay in the clients home type and just coming to feed and walk type

Availability updated 17 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Suzanne G.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Suzanne G.
Verified Background Check

8. Suzanne G.

Special care for special pets.
Riverhead, NY, 11901
2.1 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care
from
$95
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
41 reviews
13 repeat clients
Profile image

We are so thankful that our first experience using Rover and a dog sitter was with Suzanne. We had never left our dogs with anyone other than family or let someone stay in our home before booking with Suzanne for the first time. She kept us up to date with messages and pictures while we were away and left our home as she found. Most importantly our two dogs well taken care of. We will most certainly be booking with her again.

Availability updated 13 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Alexa C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Alexa C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

9. Alexa C.

Just a girl who LOVES animals 💜
Middle Island, NY, 11953
10.3 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$36
per night
1 review

Alexa has taken care of my dogs for several years. She is the most loving and caring person I have ever seen with a pet. She always makes sure their needs are being met. I don't know what we would do without her. My 2 dogs actually wait at the door for her, and cry when she leaves. If your looking for help with your pet there is nobody better!

Availability updated yesterday
Confirmed availability for Memorial Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Emily S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Emily S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

10. Emily S.

Rover 101
Local, reliable, and experienced !
Hampton bays, NY, 11946
13.8 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$110
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
28 reviews
5 repeat clients
Profile image

Emily is wonderful. Our dogs are getting older and require medication, one requires an insulin shot. Emily handled them seamlessly and with great care. We’re so glad we found her!

Availability updated today
Sitter Profile Image: Diego R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Diego R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

11. Diego R.

The most responsible caregiver
Long Island, NY, 11955
11.8 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$50
per night
3 reviews

Diego did an amazing job taking care of my dog, Coco! From the start, he was professional, caring, and attentive to all of Coco’s needs. I could tell that Coco felt comfortable and happy in his care. Diego kept me updated with pictures and messages, which gave me peace of mind while I was away. I highly recommend him to anyone looking for a trustworthy and loving pet sitter!!

Availability updated 54 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Chris D.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Chris D.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

12. Chris D.

Star Sitter
Treat your pets like your loved one
Rocky Point, NY, 11778
8.9 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$75
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
35 reviews
11 repeat clients
Profile image

Chris is awesome! He was so easy to communicate with and you can tell he really loves dogs. I do not trust my dog with anyone outside the family, but I do trust him with Chris for 2 most important reasons. He has health issues and needs medication, and he is a runner. Being a Hound, he can even get away from me! It is very difficult to keep him safe. I trust Chris with him totally. I can rest easy when he is with Chris, and I do not have to worry about him being in a crate all day. Thank You Chris for being there for us!

Availability updated 2 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Kim C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Kim C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

13. Kim C.

Opening nokill shelter in 2 years!
Middle Island, NY, 11953
10.5 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$65
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
48 reviews
21 repeat clients
Profile image

Kim was a fantastic dog sitter! She was friendly, reliable, and great with my dog! While I was out of town she stayed at my place with my dog. I never felt like I couldn’t reach her or didn’t know what was going on. She reached out regularly with updates and photos which were greatly appreciated. Thank you Kim!

Availability updated 3 months ago
Sitter Profile Image: Carey V.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Carey V.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

14. Carey V.

Your pets new best friend :)
Sound Beach, NY, 11789
12.2 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$24
per night
1 review

Carey has watched our dog, Bear, on a number of occasions and she is our go to if we need help. She is reliable, trustworthy and pet friendly. The clincher is that Bear loves her - dogs know :) I do not hesitate in recommending her.

Availability updated 5 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Kaysha H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Kaysha H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

15. Kaysha H.

Pet Appeaser, People Pleaser
Hampton Bays, NY, 11946
13.5 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits
from
$45
per night
5 reviews

Our dog LOVES Kaysha! She has watched Leigh Leigh multiple times, and is great at communicating with us when we’re away. She bonded with her quickly, and I never have to worry when she takes care of her. I would recommend her to all! Thanks Kaysha!

Availability updated 31 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Christine K.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Christine K.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

16. Christine K.

Love any animal, fuzzy or fluffy!
Farmingville, NY, 11738
16.7 mi. away
House Sitting, Dog Walking
from
$65
per night
2 reviews

Christine has been my cat sitter for almost 5 years. She just doesn't feed the cats but she genuinely enjoys playing with them and interacting with them. When going away on vacation, I do not have to worry about my cats because I know that she will take great care of them. One of my cats is on prescription food and she makes sure he doesn't eat any other cats' food.

Availability updated 6 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Anica E.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Anica E.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

17. Anica E.

Star Sitter
LVT w/over 25 years in animal care.
Bridgehampton, NY, 11932
23.2 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$58
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
28 reviews
8 repeat clients
Profile image

I almost don't want to leave this review, because Anica is so fabulous I don't want anyone else to snatch her up! Anica is just what you are looking for in a pet sitter...we have two Tibetan spaniel rescues from ARF, one is very friendly and active, while the other one is terribly shy. She managed both of them brilliantly. I will definitely hire her again and again and again...Now I can have a social life! Thank you Anica!

Availability updated 3 months ago
Sitter Profile Image: Bernadette B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Bernadette B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

18. Bernadette B.

Life’s better with a fur bestie
Patchogue, NY, 11772
20.1 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$80
per night
5 out of 5.0 stars
4 reviews

I’ve seen my friend Bernadette work absolute magic with animals. She’s a total natural when it comes to caring for pets of all kinds. Whether it’s taking dogs on walks, playing with them, giving them belly rubs, or just curling up for cuddle time, she does it all with genuine love and patience. She has a great sense of each animal’s personality and always adjusts her approach to make them feel comfortable and happy. Treat time is always fun and structured with her, and she never misses when it comes to routines or special care instructions. The same goes for cats and all indoor pets she’s gentle, attentive, and always makes sure they feel safe and cared for. Bernadette has a calm energy that animals seem to really respond to, and it’s clear how much she enjoys spending time with them. Any pet in her care is not only safe, but also truly loved.

Availability updated today
Confirmed availability for Memorial Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Kira D.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Kira D.
Verified Background Check

19. Kira D.

Versatile pet sitter in CT
Shelton, CT, 06484
31.4 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$60
per night
5 out of 4.8 stars
25 reviews
7 repeat clients
Profile image

Kira is a wonder house/dog sitter! During our meet and greet she was thoughtful and considerate. She immediately bonded with our two dogs and they settled down right away. She listened to everything I had to say about their different personalities and was so respectful and attentive the whole time. We will definitely ask her back! Hey

Availability updated 11 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Ruby Sky R.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Ruby Sky R.
Verified Background Check

20. Ruby Sky R.

Rover 101
Experienced Pet Care Individual
Patchogue, NY, 11772
19.5 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$75
per night
5 out of 4.5 stars
14 reviews
3 repeat clients
Profile image

Ruby did an excellent job taking care of my 2 dogs, and was very accommodating regarding scheduling on short notice. My friend who was supposed to pet sit fell through, so I was left looking for someone on a Tuesday night for a Friday to Sunday petsit. Ruby responded quickly to my initial questions regarding her availability and set up a meet and greet for Thursday evening. She was very good with our dogs and kept us updated as we asked how things were a few times during the weekend. The pups were very happy and contented when we got back on Sunday. Ruby did a great job and we will definitely be looking to use her in the future.

Availability updated 3 days ago
Confirmed availability for Memorial Day Weekend

The median cost per night for house sitting in Baiting Hollow is $55

How Rover works

  1. 1. Search

    Read verified reviews and choose a house sitter who’s a great match for you and your pets
  2. 2. Meet & Greet

    Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your house and pets while you’re away
  3. 3. Book & Pay

    All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!

Why Choose Rover?

  • Cashless payments

    Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.

  • Reservation protection

    It doesn’t happen often, but if your house sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.

  • World-class support

    We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total pet fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.

Sitters in Baiting Hollow average 3 repeat house sitting clients

House Sitting FAQs

Frequently asked questions about Rover

Connect anywhere with the Rover app

Download on the App Store BadgeGet it on Google Play Badge