Cat Sitting in Water Island

Book a cat sitter to stop by your home to feed and play with your cat.

Search

Every sitter passes an enhanced background check. Learn about RoverProtect

Top rated Water Island cat sitters

1 / 1
Sitter Profile Image: Michelle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Michelle H.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
34 reviews
15 repeat clients
20 years of experience
Bohemia, NY, 11716

Michele was very attentive to my cat's needs, and did a wonderful job of making my pet feel comfortable and cared for on a simple check in visit. I would definitely rebook.

Profile image
Brendan W.
Sitter Profile Image: Madison R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Madison R.
Star Sitter
from
$22
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
23 reviews
8 repeat clients
14 years of experience
Holtsville, NY, 11742

Madison was incredibly easy to communicate with and I felt reassured that our beloved cat, Jackie, was well cared for. Madison was able to accommodate a last-minute cat sitting request just in time for the holidays. I am very appreciative and would recommend Madison for any pet sitting needs.

Profile image
Paige W.
Sitter Profile Image: Amber O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amber O.
Star Sitter
from
$23
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
25 reviews
4 repeat clients
15 years of experience
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

She has been doing an excellent job keeping me informed every day and sending me pictures I highly recommend amber and will be using her in the future

Profile image
Tara D.
Sitter Profile Image: Samantha S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Samantha S.
Star Sitter
from
$25
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
26 reviews
5 repeat clients
25 years of experience
Sayville, NY, 11782

Highly recommend!! Samantha was professional, experienced and kind. She took extra loving care of our kitty Layla for an entire week while administering oral medications twice daily. I am forever grateful! Thank you!!

Profile image
EVON M.
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa & Michael W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Lisa & Michael W.
Star Sitter
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
207 reviews
82 repeat clients
40 years of experience
East patchogue, NY, 11772

I booked the drop-in visits and I couldn’t be happier with the care my cat received. Lisa and Michael were so reliable, responsive, and truly went above and beyond! I got daily updates with photos and detailed notes, and it was clear my cat was happy and well cared for. It gave me peace of mind while I was away. Highly recommend and would definitely book again. Thank you so much!

Profile image
Luyue W.
Sitter Profile Image: Christiana F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Christiana F.
Star Sitter
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
7 reviews
3 repeat clients
4 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

She was wonderful! My cat took to her almost immediately and my cat is very scared oof strangers.

Profile image
Deborah W.
Sitter Profile Image: Ashley C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Ashley C.
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
7 reviews
6 repeat clients
6 years of experience
BluePoint, NY, 11715

Ashley was very responsive and communicative. It was my first time using Rover and I was so happy Ashley was there to help out. Lots of cute pics and updates!

Profile image
Claire F.
Sitter Profile Image: Steff S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Steff S.
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
23 reviews
8 repeat clients
20 years of experience
East Islip, NY, 11730

Steff was amazing! I booked her services while I was away in Egypt, and having her care for Mylo while I was on the other side of the world gave me so much peace of mind. She was responsive, reliable, and did her best to bond with my skittish cat. I really appreciated the updates and photos of him too. Highly recommend and will book her again in the future! ❤️

Profile image
Lynda E.
Sitter Profile Image: Kaileigh H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Kaileigh H.
Star Sitter
from
$29
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
29 reviews
11 repeat clients
13 years of experience
Oakdale, NY, 11769

Kaileigh is the BEST pet sitter! She took good care of Miaui and handled unexpected situations with grace and kindness! I highly recommend her and hooe to be able to use her again. Thank you, Kaileigh, from me and Miaui! ❤️

Profile image
Alice R A.
Sitter Profile Image: Marianna D.
Verified Background Check
Marianna D.
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
9 reviews
3 repeat clients
16 years of experience
Sayville, NY, 11782

I could not be happier with how Marianna took care of my cat. Kunkcles was well taken care of while I was away. Marianna did everything I asked. I will definitely return to her in the future if she is available.

Profile image
Erik H.
Sitter Profile Image: chelsea s.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
chelsea s.
from
$18
per visit
15 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

Chelsea was such a great care taker of my 2 outdoor cats. She met with us before our booking. She even took care of a package while were away. Pictures were sent every day. Thank you Chelsea.

Profile image
Jennifer
Sitter Profile Image: Steven H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Steven H.
from
$17
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
3 reviews
20 years of experience
Bellport, NY, 11713

Steven is awesome, he took great care of my Molly. He was very communicative and sent me a lot of photos. He is an amazing guy and I will definitely book again. Highly recommended!

Profile image
Michelle H.
Sitter Profile Image: Ariana B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Ariana B.
from
$23
per visit
20 years of experience
Bohemia, NY, 11716

About: Hi! I’m Ariana — a lifelong animal lover who’s had dogs my entire life. I’m available on weekends and provide a calm, loving environment for your pup to relax, play, and feel at home. Whether it’s belly rubs, long walks, or just keeping them company, I make sure they feel safe and happy while you’re away. I treat every dog like family — because that’s how it should be. 🐶💛 I’m familiar with all kinds of temperaments and routines, and I’m happy to follow any special instructions to make your pup feel secure and loved. Let me know what your dog needs to feel comfortable — I’m here to help them have a great time while you enjoy peace of mind. I currently work full time, so I am available all day on weekends. I can accommodate weekday evenings as needed as well. I am flexible! Your pet’s safety and comfort are my top priorities. I provide a calm, secure environment where animals feel relaxed, respected, and cared for like family. I always follow your instructions carefully and maintain a clean, pet-friendly space free from hazards. I make sure they’re never left unattended in unsafe situations. I pay close attention to their behavior and body language to make sure they’re happy and stress-free. You can trust that your pet is in kind, capable hands — I treat every animal with patience, gentleness, and the same love I’ve given to my own pets all my life.

Sitter Profile Image: Nicole A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Nicole A.
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
5 reviews
1 repeat client
30 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

Nicole was great! My dog was so happy to see her and she spent time playing with him and giving him attention. I could tell because she sent me pictures of Marley smiling! We will be asking her to take care of Marley again!

Profile image
Kathleen M.
Sitter Profile Image: Julie P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Julie P.
from
$17
per visit
5 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

About: I have been care for other peoples animals for at least the five years. I grew up with cats and a dog. I am an animal lover and treat them as family. I can be flexible for care. My other work involves flexible hours teaching. I can be available with possible short notice as well. Thank you for trusting me with your fur loves. I will use resources you ask me to. Example could be leash. I will use care and courteous strategy. I find care for animals brings me joy.

Sitter Profile Image: Heather L.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Heather L.
from
$23
per visit
5 years of experience
Oakdale, NY, 11769

About: I’m here to help when you just don’t have the time to do it all! Services include: -Pet sitting for cats and dogs in the comfort of your own home -Feeding, daily visits -scoop litter boxes -play with pets I absolutely love animals and will treat your pets like they are my own. I have lots of experience with senior and special needs dogs & cats! I am a full time pet sitter who has open availability starting Feb 1st 2025. I am new to this area but I have had my pet sitting business for 5 years in Marietta GA. I care for your pets in the comfort of your own home. I offer 30 minutes to overnight visits. There is a 30 minute minimum for cats and a 60 minute minimum for dogs. I treat your pets like they are my own, with plenty of love!

Sitter Profile Image: Amanda P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Amanda P.
from
$23
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
3 reviews
5 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

Amanda was very communicative and took great, loving care of my two kitties. Highly recommended and would book again.

Profile image
Aaron H.
Sitter Profile Image: Bradley T.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Bradley T.
from
$17
per visit
8 years of experience
Patchogue, NY, 11772

About: I have always had a special connection to animals in understanding them deeply providing them with the best love and care I can possibly give them 🐾💙 I am currently take care of my cat Alley every day, feeding her, cleaning her litterbox as needed and given her tons of affection and play time as well🐾💙 I currently have a fenced yard with indoor and outdoor cats but used to have a dog that I walked and took care of with my family🐾💙

Sitter Profile Image: Jay J.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Jay J.
from
$14
per visit
5 years of experience
East Patchogue, NY, 11772

About: I’ve taken care of pets for about 5 years, have a German Shepherd of my own so I can handle pretty much everything and anything I Currently work full time until about 4:00 on weekdays, anytime after works with my schedule. Please let me know well in advance, thank you! I will abide by every rule and direction given to make sure your pet gets the best care possible, safety and satisfaction is number one priority!

Sitter Profile Image: Marisa R.
Verified Background Check
Marisa R.
from
$30
per visit
5 out of 4.9 stars
108 reviews
51 repeat clients
6 years of experience
Fire Island, NY, 11782

I am so thankful we found Marisa!! Overall a great experience and we will definitely be using Marisa again ?

Profile image
Rhona L.
1 / 1
View more sitters

Loving cat sitters in your neighborhood

Search Results

Sitter Profile Image: Michelle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Michelle H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Michelle H.
Star Sitter

Top-Notch Care for Your Fur Babies
Bohemia, NY, 11716
6.9 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
34 reviews
15 repeat clients
Profile image

Michele was very attentive to my cat's needs, and did a wonderful job of making my pet feel comfortable and cared for on a simple check in visit. I would definitely rebook.

Availability updated today
Sitter Profile Image: Madison R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Madison R.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Madison R.
Star Sitter

happiest when with animals
Holtsville, NY, 11742
10.3 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$22
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
23 reviews
8 repeat clients
Profile image

Madison was incredibly easy to communicate with and I felt reassured that our beloved cat, Jackie, was well cared for. Madison was able to accommodate a last-minute cat sitting request just in time for the holidays. I am very appreciative and would recommend Madison for any pet sitting needs.

Availability updated 3 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Amber O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Amber O.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Amber O.
Star Sitter

Compassionate and Reliable
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779
10.7 mi. away
Boarding, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care
from
$23
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
25 reviews
4 repeat clients
Profile image

She has been doing an excellent job keeping me informed every day and sending me pictures I highly recommend amber and will be using her in the future

Availability updated 6 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Samantha S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Samantha S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Samantha S.
Star Sitter

Responsible pet loving military vet
Sayville, NY, 11782
5.2 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$25
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
26 reviews
5 repeat clients
Profile image

Highly recommend!! Samantha was professional, experienced and kind. She took extra loving care of our kitty Layla for an entire week while administering oral medications twice daily. I am forever grateful! Thank you!!

Availability updated 3 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa & Michael W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Lisa & Michael W.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Lisa & Michael W.
Star Sitter

Welcoming your fur babies 😊🐶🐱
East patchogue, NY, 11772
6.3 mi. away
Boarding, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
207 reviews
82 repeat clients
Profile image

I booked the drop-in visits and I couldn’t be happier with the care my cat received. Lisa and Michael were so reliable, responsive, and truly went above and beyond! I got daily updates with photos and detailed notes, and it was clear my cat was happy and well cared for. It gave me peace of mind while I was away. Highly recommend and would definitely book again. Thank you so much!

Availability updated 23 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Christiana F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Christiana F.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Christiana F.
Star Sitter

Giants welcome, cuddles are free!
Patchogue, NY, 11772
5.3 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
7 reviews
3 repeat clients
Profile image

She was wonderful! My cat took to her almost immediately and my cat is very scared oof strangers.

Availability updated 13 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Ashley C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Ashley C.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Ashley C.

Hello my name is Ashley
BluePoint, NY, 11715
4.5 mi. away
Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
7 reviews
6 repeat clients
Profile image

Ashley was very responsive and communicative. It was my first time using Rover and I was so happy Ashley was there to help out. Lots of cute pics and updates!

Availability updated 10 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Steff S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Steff S.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Steff S.

Pets are family,instantly love them
East Islip, NY, 11730
9.1 mi. away
Boarding, House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
23 reviews
8 repeat clients
Profile image

Steff was amazing! I booked her services while I was away in Egypt, and having her care for Mylo while I was on the other side of the world gave me so much peace of mind. She was responsive, reliable, and did her best to bond with my skittish cat. I really appreciated the updates and photos of him too. Highly recommend and will book her again in the future! ❤️

Availability updated 2 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Kaileigh H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Kaileigh H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Kaileigh H.
Star Sitter

Love animals of all kinds!
Oakdale, NY, 11769
6.7 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$29
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
29 reviews
11 repeat clients
Profile image

Kaileigh is the BEST pet sitter! She took good care of Miaui and handled unexpected situations with grace and kindness! I highly recommend her and hooe to be able to use her again. Thank you, Kaileigh, from me and Miaui! ❤️

Availability updated yesterday
Sitter Profile Image: Marianna D.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Marianna D.
Verified Background Check

Marianna D.

Trustworthy and always punctual
Sayville, NY, 11782
5.4 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$20
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
9 reviews
3 repeat clients
Profile image

I could not be happier with how Marianna took care of my cat. Kunkcles was well taken care of while I was away. Marianna did everything I asked. I will definitely return to her in the future if she is available.

Availability updated today
Sitter Profile Image: chelsea s.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: chelsea s.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

chelsea s.

Hey my name is Chelsea!!!
Patchogue, NY, 11772
6.6 mi. away
Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$18
per visit
15 years of experience
Profile image

Chelsea was such a great care taker of my 2 outdoor cats. She met with us before our booking. She even took care of a package while were away. Pictures were sent every day. Thank you Chelsea.

Availability updated 24 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Steven H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Steven H.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Steven H.

Treating your pets like my own.
Bellport, NY, 11713
7.7 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$17
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
3 reviews
Profile image

Steven is awesome, he took great care of my Molly. He was very communicative and sent me a lot of photos. He is an amazing guy and I will definitely book again. Highly recommended!

Availability updated 13 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Ariana B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Ariana B.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Ariana B.

Snuggles, Walks & Tail Wags
Bohemia, NY, 11716
7.6 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$23
per visit
2 reviews

If you ever wanted to meet Snow White in person, Ariana would be it! She is a true animal lover and cares for each one like her own. She is great with starting slow and taking it easy with pets that may exhibit anxiety for the first few visits, but she's ready to play and give belly rubs on command! Ariana is trustworthy and responsible and will go above and beyond to make your dog feel loved and well cared for.

Availability updated 4 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Nicole A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Nicole A.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Nicole A.

Warm heart for cold noses
Patchogue, NY, 11772
5.8 mi. away
Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$18
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
5 reviews
1 repeat client
Profile image

Nicole was great! My dog was so happy to see her and she spent time playing with him and giving him attention. I could tell because she sent me pictures of Marley smiling! We will be asking her to take care of Marley again!

Availability updated 15 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Julie P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Julie P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Julie P.

I treat your pets like family.
Patchogue, NY, 11772
6.0 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Doggy Day Care, Dog Walking
from
$17
per visit
1 review

I've been using Julie to walk my dog for years, and I couldn't be happier with the care and attention she provide. My dog Penny, who can be a little shy around new people, quickly warmed up thanks to her calm and friendly nature. She has is always punctual, reliable, and communicates clearly after every walk—often with photos or little updates that brighten my day. It’s such a relief knowing my dog is in good hands when I’m not home. I highly recommend Julie to anyone looking for a trustworthy and genuinely to care for their pet.

Availability updated 10 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Heather L.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Heather L.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Heather L.

Let Heather Help
Oakdale, NY, 11769
5.8 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits
from
$23
per visit
5 reviews

Heather is the best pet sitter we have ever had! We have a lot of pets with a lot of personalities and needs, she is very mindful and attentive to each of them individually. We have left our 5 cats and big dog with her for both short overnighters and long 2+ week trips and we always come home to happy animals who are still comfortably within their routines. Our dog Bean loves Heather and our finicky cats warmed up to her very quickly. We always felt safe and comfortable leaving our babies in her care!

Availability updated 54 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Amanda P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Amanda P.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Amanda P.

Your Pet’s New Best Friend
Patchogue, NY, 11772
6.0 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$23
per visit
5 out of 5.0 stars
3 reviews
Profile image

Amanda was very communicative and took great, loving care of my two kitties. Highly recommended and would book again.

Availability updated today
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Bradley T.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Bradley T.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Bradley T.

Animal Lover🐾💙
Patchogue, NY, 11772
5.8 mi. away
House Sitting, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$17
per visit
8 years of experience

About: I have always had a special connection to animals in understanding them deeply providing them with the best love and care I can possibly give them 🐾💙 I am currently take care of my cat Alley every day, feeding her, cleaning her litterbox as needed and given her tons of affection and play time as well🐾💙 I currently have a fenced yard with indoor and outdoor cats but used to have a dog that I walked and took care of with my family🐾💙

Availability updated 13 days ago
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend
Sitter Profile Image: Jay J.
Verified Enhanced Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Jay J.
Verified Enhanced Background Check

Jay J.

Your pet is family
East Patchogue, NY, 11772
5.4 mi. away
Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$14
per visit
2 reviews

Jay was the first person to look after my German Shepard as he has separation anxiety and he did a excellent job. He took care of my puppy and I would recommend him to anyone who needs there loved one taken care of with love. He did an excellent job at making my puppy feel comfortable and safe!

Availability updated 69 days ago
Sitter Profile Image: Marisa R.
Verified Background Check
Sitter Profile Image: Marisa R.
Verified Background Check

Marisa R.
Rover 101

Attentive and loving animal care
Fire Island, NY, 11782
3.1 mi. away
Boarding, Drop-In Visits, Dog Walking
from
$30
per visit
5 out of 4.9 stars
108 reviews
51 repeat clients
Profile image

I am so thankful we found Marisa!! Overall a great experience and we will definitely be using Marisa again ?

Availability updated today
Confirmed availability for Labor Day Weekend

How Rover works

  1. 1. Search

    Read verified reviews by cat parents like you and choose a sitter who’s a great match for you and your cat
  2. 2. Meet & Greet

    Meet either virtually or in-person with a sitter to discuss the level of care needed for your cat while you’re away
  3. 3. Book & Pay

    All payments are processed through Rover’s secured platform and your booking is backed by 24/7 support. It’s that easy!

Why Choose Rover?

  • Cashless payments

    Book and pay through Rover’s secured platform—no cash or checks required.

  • Reservation protection

    It doesn’t happen often, but if your cat sitter has to cancel, we’ll work with you to find a new sitter.

  • World-class support

    We’re friendly, knowledgable, and total cat fanatics. You can get in touch with us anytime.

Cat Sitting FAQs

Frequently asked questions about Rover