- This post contains affiliate links. Read more here.
- Not a substitute for professional veterinary help.
Pet parents know that peanut butters and spreadable treats for dogs are incredibly useful and versatile. They can be added to lick mats or other puzzle food dispensers. They’re great for baking or using as a frozen treat. They work as a meal-topper on dry kibble, and they even help the medicine go down. With so many options out there, we’ve selected some of the best peanut butters for dogs for pet parents to consider.
Peanut butters are also calorie-rich, which means there’s an art to incorporating them in your pet’s diet. “When people use fillers, it’s surprisingly often the reason that their dogs are overweight and they don’t even realize it,” says Dr. Rebecca Greenstein, Veterinary Medical Advisor for Rover and Chief Veterinarian at Kleinburg Veterinary Hospital.
It’s important to note that dog-specific peanut butters are preferable to the cheaper human options you find in your grocery store. Products made for dogs typically cut back on the fat, sugar, and salt, which a canine palate won’t miss, to prioritize nutritious, dog-safe ingredients. If you aren’t sure of the best treat for your dog, check out our resources on choosing the right dog treat.
Best All-Around Peanut Butter for Dogs: Big Spoon Roasters Wag Butter
Big Spoon Roasters Wag Butter contains just three ingredients: peanuts, bananas, and flax. It has no added sugar, salt, hydrogenated oils, palm oils, or other product stabilizers. This recipe balances protein, Omega-3, and Omega-6 to promote healthy muscles, joints, skin, and coats. Flaxseed, added to aid in digestion, is also a source of antioxidants to fight inflammation.
It’s a little messy—better for lick mats than KONGs—but it gets high marks among pup tasters.
- 90 kcal/tbsp
- 50% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 6% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 4% carbohydrate (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Peanuts, banana, golden flaxseed meal.
Find on AmazonBest Dog Peanut Butter for Flavor Variety: Bark Bistro Buddy Budder
Buddy Budder stands out among the competition for its wide range of flavors. In addition to this honey recipe, Buddy Budder comes in apple, banana, bacon, pumpkin, and berry recipes. We like it for picky eaters who need a rotating diet. This particular recipe includes only non-salted peanut butter and wildflower honey and contains about 85 calories per tablespoon. It also features a nice balance of proteins, healthy fats, antioxidants, manganese, and Vitamin E.
Buddy Budder is one of the easiest dog peanut butters to serve when it’s stored in the fridge, and we find it spreads easily on lick mats and fillable toys alike.
- 85 kcal/tbsp
- 16.5% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 77% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 6% carbohydrate (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Unsalted Peanuts, Wildflower Honey.
Find on Chewy Find on AmazonBest Dog Peanut Butter for Baking: Nature’s Logic Peanut Butter
This peanut butter uses only three ingredients: peanuts, chia seeds, and coconut oil. The chia seeds provide omega-3 fatty acids that can help support healthy skin and a shiny coat. The coconut oil is also good for a healthy coat, but pet parents should note that dogs with sensitivities to some fats may not digest this recipe as well as one without added oils.
The coconut oil also makes this recipe a mess at warmer temperatures: the recipe will separate, so it should be kept in the refrigerator to help maintain consistency. It’s a tricky option for hiding pills or spreading on lick mats, but it’s great for baking or incorporating into homemade baked dog treats.
- 124 calories per tbsp
- 16% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 80% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 4% carbohydrates (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Peanuts, Chia Seeds, Coconut Oil.
Find on Chewy Find on AmazonBest Single-Serving Dog Peanut Butter Spread: Café Nära Peanut Butter
Cafe Nara’s recipe is a low-calorie and creamy snack packaged in serving-sized tube. This recipe is free of grain, corn, wheat, added sugar, or artificial flavors. Pet parents like its versatility: it can be served directly from the tube, squirted on top of your dog’s food, or frozen on hot days. This recipe includes a few extra ingredients, such as starch, egg whites, and sunflower oil. If your dog has sensitivities to foods, which can make it a no-go for some dogs with food allergies.
In terms of convenience, however, it’s hard to beat, and it makes an excellent training lure for high-prey-drive dogs.
- 40 kcal/tbsp
- 16% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 80% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 4% carbohydrates (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Water, Peanut Butter, Tapioca Starch, Yeast Extract, Egg Whites, Sunflower Oil.
Find on Chewy Find on AmazonBest Portable Dog Peanut Butter Spread: Whole Hearted Lovable Lickables
Whole Hearted’s spreadable treats include three ingredients: peanuts, pumpkin, and oatmeal. We like that it comes in a convenient pouch (though it’s worth noting that the manufacturer recommends refrigerating for a thicker consistency). At 90 kcal/tbsp, this peanut butter snack is in the mid-range of calories per serving. We especially like the mix of high-fiber pumpkin, which can help regulate sensitive stomachs.
- 90 kcal/tbsp
- 14% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 78% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 8% carbohydrate (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Peanuts, oatmeal, pumpkin.
Find on PetcoBest High-Calorie Spreadable Dog Treat: Fruitables Spoonable Spreadable Bakeable
This spreadable dog treat is a fun take on peanut butter snacks, and it also includes fruit. Peanut butter is the primary ingredient, but molasses, apple, cinnamon, and pumpkin add extra flavor—and fiber. This treat is free from gluten, soy, wheat, and corn, and can be fed as-is or baked into your dog’s favorite homemade treat. At 97 kcal/tbsp, this is a high-calorie snack.
- 97 kcal/tbsp
- 12% protein (by dry matter weight)
- 70% fat (by dry matter weight)
- 18% carbohydrate (by dry matter weight)
Best High-Protein Peanut Butter for Dogs: Dilly’s Poochie Butter
Dilly’s Pooch Butter contains no artificial flavors or preservatives and has only three ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, flaxseed, and pumpkin. It’s a popular treat for giving pills and spreading inside toys and on lick mats. The relatively high protein content will be of interest to pet parents with highly active and working pups—though it’s worth noting that the manufacturer recommends serving only one tablespoon per day.
- 79 kcal/tbsp
- 19% protein (by dry matter weight)
- 76% fat (by dry matter weight)
- 5% carbohydrate (by dry matter weight)
Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, flaxseed, pumpkin.
Find on AmazonBest Dog Peanut Butter for Lick Mats and Toys: Green Coast Pet Pawnut Butter
Green Coast Pawnut Butter with Coconut contains only peanuts, dried coconut, and dried coconut oil. The recipe uses no salt, sugar, preservatives, hydrogenated oil, gluten, soy, corn, or wheat. Like most peanut butters for dogs, it also has no xylitol. This treat is easy to spread and works great as a treat, to hide pills, or to use with toys and lick mats.
- 17% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 78% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 5% carbohydrate (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: ground peanuts, dried coconut, coconut oil.
Find on AmazonBest Peanut Butter for Joint Support: Paw Power Dawg Butter for Hips and Joints
Paw Power Daw Butter for Hips and Joints contains ingredients that support joint and immune health, including glucosamine, chondroitin, MSM, turmeric, and cranberries. We think it’s an especially nice choice for senior dogs and picky eaters who need their supplements disguised. Like most peanut butter spreads for dogs, this formula is free from xylitol and gluten. The manufacturer recommends feeding amounts based on the weight of your dog, but as with all supplements, pet parents should check in with their vet before feeding.
- 17% protein (by dry weight matter)
- 78% fat (by dry weight matter)
- 5% carbohydrate (by dry weight matter)
Ingredients: Peanuts, glucosamine, chondroitin, MSM, turmeric, cranberries, honey.
Find on AmazonHow We Chose
The products featured here were selected based on a combination of our own hands-on testing, a comprehensive look at customer reviews across a wide variety of retail platforms, and interviews with veterinary experts. We weighed calories per tablespoon, ingredient lists, and texture and consistency to bring you the best dog peanut butters and spreadable treats. We’re also guided by the experience of living and playing alongside our own much-loved and strongly opinionated pets, who are never stingy with their feedback.
