- This post contains affiliate links. Read more here.
Cats and mice go together like peanut butter and jelly…if peanut butter was driven to hunt and capture jelly, that is. In fact, mouse cat toys are incredibly popular because they harness cats’ natural instincts to chase and play with small prey. Whether you have a new kitten you want to keep busy, or an older cat who needs some exercise, mouse toys are a great pick.
With so many mouse cat toys around, it can be difficult to know which one to buy. That’s why we’ve read through hundreds of online reviews to find our favorite mouse cat toys for 2019.
These soft, overstuffed mice are made from recycled, reclaimed, renewable, and organic materials. Plus, they’re packed with potent catnip to grab your cat’s attention. If you’re tired of cat toys getting shredded to pieces and leaving fur all over the place, these are nice alternative.
Helpful review: “I have two cats—a very energetic Siamese cat (Loki) and a less active older cat (Cyd) and they both love these catnip mice toys. The toys are very lightweight, and I really like that they’re not made from fur.”Buy Now on Amazon for $2.09
Is your cat a wand toy fiend? This “teaser” has a cute little mouse with a long tail attached to a flexible wire. Flick the wand around, drag the “mouse” along the floor, and watch your cat’s inner hunter emerge. And if your cat catches the mouse one too many times, don’t worry—you can purchase replacements that clip on to the wire with ease.
Helpful review: “I love the toy because both kittens are teething and, unlike toys with elastic or string lines, which my kittens destroy in one session, the braided metal wire in this toy lasts and lasts. There’s something special about this toy, which makes my kittens go wild…One caveat: This toy requires that a person supervise all play.”Buy Now on Amazon for $10.47
If your cat is intrigued by sounds, they’ll love this mouse toy. The catnip stuffing and soft fake fur will catch their attention, and once they start batting it around, they’ll be rewarded by a realistic squeak. Just be sure to let guests and other family members know this isn’t a real mouse…
Helpful review: “My little guys pretend this toy mouse is the real thing. I throw, they chase and ‘catch’, and proceed to toss it up in the air. Its squeak is very realistic and it even looks like a mouse.”Buy Now on Amazon for $18.93
Does your cat ever snag your fingers while you’re playing with him or her? This interactive cat mouse toy offers a simple, yet very effective, solution. The toy comes with a ring that slips over your finger, giving you control of an adorable mouse puppet that bobs up and down at the end of a bungee cord. This bouncing motion entices your cat to play, and the different textures of the toy make it extra-fun once they catch their prey.
Helpful review: “This cute little mouse has been flung all over the front room. My kitty is a flinger of toys. We have hung it on different things and he also loves to bat at it.”Buy Now on Chewy for $2.99
Is it a mouse cat toy? Is it a bird cat toy? It’s both! This fuzzy mouse has fluffy feathers for a tail, making it perfect for the cat that loves to hunt. Plus, it’s filled with premium North American catnip and has a “hidden” closure that lets you open and refresh the catnip supply over time. It even comes with a free refill.
Helpful review: “My cat absolutely loved this. He’s obsessed with catnip and is very playful. We only lost half of the feathers in the past few weeks, but that’s to be expected. The cat could definitely smell the catnip and he loved the feathers. Highly recommend, especially because it’s refillable!”Buy Now on Amazon for $6.68
Mouse cat toys come in all different colors, sizes, and materials. To keep your cat a happy hunter, be sure to stock up on their favorites.
Need Cat Sitting?
Cats seem more independent than dogs, sure, but they need attention, play, and treats when you’re gone, too. Your great cat deserves great cat care. You’ve found the best cat toys, so now it’s time to find them the perfect cat sitter.
New Cat Resources
If you’re adding a kitten or a newly adopted cat to your family, these articles will help you both get off on the right paw.