score:
0

Can dogs fake injuries for pity?

I have two dogs. The male has bad hips and limps around and gets "special" treatments because of his disability like being carried or lifted places, and I massage his hip muscles when I can. I try to treat my female equally, (she gets peanut butter when I give him some for medicine and she gets pets after his massage) but she doesn't need to be carried or lifted onto the couch and bed.

I have noticed my female get's irritated when she does not get the same treatment as the male. Recently she has started limping, and after watching her I noticed she switches feet like a child trying to fake it.

Do dogs have the mental capacity to understand why one receives special treatment and fake an injury to get the same?

2 Answers

Sort by ยป oldest newest most voted
score:
1

Oh Yes! They learn by practice and she sees that the other dog gets something by limping so she will try it too. Just as dogs learn to go out, play, lay on furniture, etc. by watching what the others do. As long as you know that she is fine, its okay. Just never reward her for doing it or she will continue.

Perhaps giving the other dog his meds or treats out of sight of the girl and give hers to her away from him might help. That way one does not know what the other is doing and you are not just singling her out with treat time. Dogs are funny little animals, they learn quickly!

score:
0

Most definitely. I use to work as a dog groomer and a regular client of mine brought her dog in for a both but was concerned about her dog because he had started limping a couple days prior. I looked the dog over and found nothing that I could see wrong. I assured her that I would accommodate her dog as needed. As soon as she left, the dog stopped limping. I called her to let her know and at pick up, I showed her that her dog was faking it by having her hide. No limp. But as soon as the dog saw her, he started limping again. It was the funniest thing.